Why should Calzaghe be p4p #1?

[Sadler]

Everyone was saying before last night that Pacquaio was going to get beat and Calzaghe was going to be #1 p4p, which would have been right if it happened, but it didnt happen and people are still trying to argue that Calzaghe is #1.

What actually happened was Pacquiao leathered De La Hoya at welterweight, stepping up 2 weight classes. Fair play to Calzaghe hes never lost but hes stayed at the same weight, and never proved himself in lighter/heavier weight classes, so how can he be p4p #1 when pacquiao has continually moved up in weight and dominated???

[larryx]

Dont listen to nutthuggers..they dont know the defintion of commonsense

[ACHlLLES]

Who the **** is saying Calzaghe is p4p number 1... That is insane, Calzaghe should stay at p4p 2 for now...

[-MAKAVELLI-]

if anything, JMM just solidified his #2 ranking

[KingTito]

Pacquiao is #1.

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

pacquiao and marquez are the best fighters in the world

[ACHlLLES]

pacquiao and marquez are the best fighters in the world

Pacquiao beat Marquez twice, and sour mexicans can't admit that to themselves. Calzaghe is p4p 2, not Marquez who lost twice to pacquiao. He can take p4p 3 spot, since he had close fights with Pacquiao but still lost em.

[-----------]

Pacman is #1.

Calzaghe is #2.

Calzaghe will only become #1 if Hatton beats Pacman and Calzaghe fights Dawson/Hopkins/................................................. maybe Froch, na wait, not him yet, would love to see it but he's not really a big enough name yet and hasn't proved himself yet, the guy needs to use all his potential first

[icantbox]

I am a huge Calzaghe fan and I have him at number 2. You can't compare anyone to pacquiao right now. He is too talented and has accomplised so much. It's not even an argument.

BTW, pac didn't meat Marquez twice. He had a win and a draw.