Dear Calzaghe

[The_One77]

beating Hopkins is better than beating a shot ODH

[Dice]

More to prove???he aint prove **** yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

He beat Hopkins at Hopkins own trash game, he smashed Roy Jones EASY doing wat Roy Jones did to opponents, he beat Mikkel Kessler, and made over 20 defenses of his title.

Who else is left?? Chad Dawson?? Please, Joe aint got nothing else to prove

[ACHlLLES]

More to prove???he aint prove **** yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

If Calzaghe hasn't proved **** yet, then what the **** has floyd prove? That Manny is a better overall fighter then him? Manny's defense and offensive game last night was more entertaining then anything floyd has ever done in his entire career.

Pacquiao beat the **** out of Oscar, and Cotto beat the **** out of Zab Judah... Floyd struggled with both of those fighters

[Nu Jerzey Devil]

beating Hopkins is better than beating a shot ODH

Shame Hopkins got robbed then ain't it.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

beating Hopkins is better than beating a shot ODH

LOL...maybe if they were the same size...PAC shi1ts on calazaghe

[Mr. Philadel]

More to prove???he aint prove **** yet!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[egreezy]

He beat Hopkins at Hopkins own trash game, he smashed Roy Jones EASY doing wat Roy Jones did to opponents, he beat Mikkel Kessler, and made over 20 defenses of his title.

Who else is left?? Chad Dawson?? Please, Joe aint got nothing else to prove

Yes Dawson who may be the best prime champion he has ever faced. And more to prove that there are two active fighters on P4P list higher then him which says alot of about his undefeated record.

If Calzaghe hasn't proved **** yet, then what the **** has floyd prove? That Manny is a better overall fighter then him? Manny's defense and offensive game last night was more entertaining then anything floyd has ever done in his entire career.

Pacquiao beat the **** out of Oscar, and Cotto beat the **** out of Zab Judah... Floyd struggled with both of those fighters

LOL Pacquiao had better strategy/style to crush Oscar. and Cotto lowblowed his way to victory against Zab after he had him hurt.

[Dan...]

He beat Hopkins at Hopkins own trash game, he smashed Roy Jones EASY doing wat Roy Jones did to opponents, he beat Mikkel Kessler, and made over 20 defenses of his title.

Who else is left?? Chad Dawson?? Please, Joe aint got nothing else to prove

Be real. Out of all of those wins you mentioned only the Kessler win is a great win, because he was a prime young champ. I give Joe heaps of credit for that win. Kessler is a beast and beating him to unify at 168 was a huge achievement.

But the BHop and RJJ wins? Come on now. Not only was the BHop win controversial, but Hopkins is in him mid 40s. I don't care that he took Kelly to pieces, that man is a fair way from what he was a few years back. And beating the near 40 year old Roy Jones that won competitive decisions over an old blown up Tito and no-name Hanshaw after being knocked the *** out twice is barely even a decent win.

Joe has proven that he is a great fighter, but he shouldn't be mentioned with the likes of Pacquiao IMO.

[southpaw83]

Calzaghe done what he had to do with his opponents

Hopkins proved against Pavlik that's he's still an elite fighter....Calzaghe IMO edged him. Even if you think Hopkins won, it was still very close and Hopkins is a surefire top 5 P4P. Pacman had similar trouble with another P4P top 5 fighter...I actually think JMM beat him.

I never understand the P4P fascination....I just appreciate both for being excellent fighters

[flipbjefrox]

He beat Hopkins at Hopkins own trash game, he smashed Roy Jones EASY doing wat Roy Jones did to opponents, he beat Mikkel Kessler, and made over 20 defenses of his title.

Who else is left?? Chad Dawson?? Please, Joe aint got nothing else to prove

he slapped jones and clearly couldnt take him out. he got kd by hopkins and jones. geez like mak said learn from pac