If Hatton beats Pacquaio

[Underdog82]

is he then pfp No.1?

Definitely.

[Silencers]

i guess but my p4p list is more resume based.

resume wise......

most p4p guys have losses to marg or willliams , darchinyan or donaire , pacquiao or hopkins , etc.

a loss to #1 p4p floyd mayweather jr. is not as bad in comparison.

a win over kostya tszyu is also better than a win over 40 yr. old roy jones , a draw against pac , a win over mosley , etc.

We have different ways of ranking them then, I mean if you're ranking Hatton in there because of his win over Tszyu then Taylor should be in there because of his wins over Hopkins etc.

[kadyo's]

the question is would he be #1 IF he beat pacquiao kadyo.

who'd you have over hatton?

that loser calzaghe? with his sorry ass wins over a 43 yr. old hopkins and 40 yr. old jones?

marquez? with his draw and loss with pacquiao?

if ricky wins...... he has a win over kostya tszyu and manny pacquiao! who the hell is gonna top that?

Who the heck is pacquiao kadyo? LOL.


Of course I agree with you too. You forgot to mention marquez moving to 135 and beat the lineal champ.

[Underdog82]

Hatton will never fight , Manny, he`s only taken one risk in his career by thinking Mayweather would not have the punching power to ko him, he picks his fights carefully any experianced boxing fan can see that Hatton would be given a hammering if he fights Manny but at the end of the day Hatton will find a way of avoiding this fight.

You are about as uninformed and clueless as they come on these forums.

[Left Hook Tua]

We have different ways of ranking them then, I mean if you're ranking Hatton in there because of his win over Tszyu then Taylor should be in there because of his wins over Hopkins etc.

taylor got into the p4p list because of hopkins.

it's only right hatton gets in because of tszyu.

hatton lost once to the #1 p4p fighter in the world. that shouldn't boot him off the list completely.

[Silencers]

taylor got into the p4p list because of hopkins.

it's only right hatton gets in because of tszyu.

hatton lost once to the #1 p4p fighter in the world. that shouldn't boot him off the list completely.

It's not just the loss, it's the lackluster performances since Maussa.

[Left Hook Tua]

Who the heck is pacquiao kadyo? LOL.


Of course I agree with you too. You forgot to mention marquez moving to 135 and beat the lineal champ.

good win for jmm.

he gets a shot at pac right after hatton.

[Left Hook Tua]

It's not just the loss, it's the lackluster performances since Maussa.

joe is #1.

you telling me he was a barnburner?

if you don't rank joe highly that's fine. he doesn't deserve it imo.

but if you have joe as your #2.

ricky deserves to be at least top 10.

[kadyo's]

good win for jmm.

he gets a shot at pac right after hatton.

If pac gets lucky again, I want to see pac-pbf, never mind that ***git JMM, let him rot in hell for being a sore loser.

[Silencers]

joe is #1.

you telling me he was a barnburner?

if you don't rank joe highly that's fine. he doesn't deserve it imo.

but if you have joe as your #2.

ricky deserves to be at least top 10.

Calzaghe's recent performances have been much better, his win over Lacy, then his wins over Kessler and Hopkins, the Hopkins win looks much better now that Hopkins dominated Pavlik. I don't rank fighters from what they accomplished 3 years ago.