Who ranks higher on your ATG list?

[Shadow boxer 3]

calzaghe not even on my list

[Shadow boxer 3]

Oscar and Calzaghe are two of my favorite fighters ever, but there's no question who is better. Oscar at his best was never anywhere near Joe's level. It's not close, they;re like five levels apart. Calzaghe is the much better competitor and champion.

the Calzaghe nuthugging on NSB is ridiculous

[Pullcounter]

Vote. Personally I don't thik it is really that close.

calz hasn't done **** but reign a weak division and beat 2 past their prime fighters. dlh has taken on everyone with a name (except winky) from 140 to 160 (and now from 106 lbs LOL). Yeah, dlh lost against the best competition, but that's less shameful than doing nothing ur whole career and then getting brave when the best of ur generation are old or shot.

[Pullcounter]

the Calzaghe nuthugging on NSB is ridiculous

I know right.... I guess you can make an argument for Calz being a better champion because of his record defenses against euro-bums, medocre fightrs, and past their prime legends, but Calz aint a better competitor than DLH.

[Savino]

The golden boy for me. moved up weights, won titles at diferent divisions and even tho he might not beat them he still fought quality fighters.

[krispy kreme]

De La Hoya, no question.

I don't see how anyone could pick Calzaghe over DLH, when you look at Calzaghe's career it looks very handpicked.