Which win was better?

[elgu]

The win JMM has over Barrera or the one Cotto has over Mosley. Both were "close" fights and in both one of the fighters was past their best.

[deevel79]

JMM's over Barrera. Cotto's win was good, but Shane was a bit past prime. Lets not forget thought that many people predicted Mosley to beat Cotto.

[DiegoFuego]

I thought Marquez won by a point in a very, very close fight while I was sure after the Cotto fight that he had beat Mosley. Plus Mosley > Barrera easily

[Pullcounter]

The win JMM has over Barrera or the one Cotto has over Mosley. Both were "close" fights and in both one of the fighters was past their best.

cotto's was better because he didn't get knocked down