Where does a VERY impressive win for Manny place him in modern history????

[COACH WEBB]

thoughts??????

[Christus Regnat]

Are you a Vatican II Catholic? Novos Ordo?

[Christus Regnat]

Lendendary definitely for the Phillipines as he is already I dont know how to rank teh modern fighters with the old generally

[NAPO]

by manny beating de la hoya.he has to be the best of this generation.


come on the guy is a 4 division champ + 1 ring belt in 126.


he started his career at 106 pounds nuff said.


and he has beat many good names.

if this doesn't make him an all time great then henry armstrong sucks.

[Dice]

If your talking about a win over Oscar, it puts him up there is a modern great. I mean he's got the Marciano syndrome of catching guys in there downturn of their careers but facts are facts, wins (with knockouts mixed in) over Oscar Larios, Erik Morales twice, Marco Antonio Barerra twice, Juan Manuel Marquez twice, and then a win over Oscar?? I mean you cant deny that

[ANDROID_DOES]

thoughts??????

ima big fan of pac but if he doesn't go back down and fight Diaz, JMM, Campbell at 135 like he said he wanted to do than i will lose respect for the guy. DLh fight ok pacman fine that's alot of money you're going to make and any man would do the same. But if he decides he wants to chase more money in hitman and then retire and leave all the 135lbers hanging then it's going to be pretty sad and he would not have gone out cementing his legacy in my eyes.

[Christus Regnat]

Lendendary definitely for the Phillipines as he is already I dont know how to rank teh modern fighters with the old generally

But I have to admit there's definitely people alot more knowedgable than me about both the current and older fighters. I tend to idolize the 90's and 80's probably to an over degree but that's the boxing I'm familiar and use as a standard I think correctly.

[Allucard]

If your talking about a win over Oscar, it puts him up there is a modern great. I mean he's got the Marciano syndrome of catching guys in there downturn of their careers but facts are facts, wins (with knockouts mixed in) over Oscar Larios, Erik Morales twice, Marco Antonio Barerra twice, Juan Manuel Marquez twice, and then a win over Oscar?? I mean you cant deny that

What you call Joe Calzaghe then?

[Dice]

ima big fan of pac but if he doesn't go back down and fight Diaz, JMM, Campbell at 135 like he said he wanted to do than i will lose respect for the guy. DLh fight ok pacman fine that's alot of money you're going to make and any man would do the same. But if he decides he wants to chase more money in hitman and then retire and leave all the 135lbers hanging then it's going to be pretty sad and he would not have gone out cementing his legacy in my eyes.

He aint going back to 135, he's in the big leagues now financially. Win or lose he's fighting Hatton at 140, win against Oscar or look good in both fights, the man is possibly in line to fight Floyd, JMM aint gettin a rematch no time soon which must pick at his brain

[COACH WEBB]

Are you a Vatican II Catholic? Novos Ordo?

sorry I am not any of thee above