How About Top 20 P4P?

[egreezy]

JMM at #1 I dont think so. And Rafa Marquez above Vazquez? whats up with that? Ad my favorite you put Dawson in the top 10, but you put Cotto 16, thats just wrong!!!!!!!!lol

I had JMM beating Pac twice. I had Raf beating Izzy. And after Cotto's next win I will move him back up a lot, the people in front of him won their last fights except Pavlik.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

I had JMM beating Pac twice. I had Raf beating Izzy. And after Cotto's next win I will move him back up a lot, the people in front of him won their last fights except Pavlik.

I just rewatched the first Pacquia vs Marquez and theres no way Marquez won that one. After 2 rounds Marquez was 5 points down, he had to pretty much won 8 of the last 12 and he didnt won 8 rounds in that fight. The second one is more debatable!!!! And about Cotto, you put him that low because he lost, WTF? You put Clottey,Dawson, Doinare, Pavlik in front of him. Cotto is still a top 10 even if he lost his last fight.Hell, you have Marquez and he lost 2 out of 3 vs Vazquez and dawson is not top ten p4P quality yet. Your being a bit bias there.!!!! But the rest I dont have a problem with!!!!!

[egreezy]

I just rewatched the first Pacquia vs Marquez and theres no way Marquez won that one. After 2 rounds Marquez was 5 points down, he had to pretty much won 8 of the last 12 and he didnt won 8 rounds in that fight. The second one is more debatable!!!! And about Cotto, you put him that low because he lost, WTF? You put Clottey,Dawson, Doinare, Pavlik in front of him. Cotto is still a top 10 even if he lost his last fight.Hell, you have Marquez and he lost 2 out of 3 vs Vazquez and dawson is not top ten p4P quality yet. Your being a bit bias there.!!!! But the rest I dont have a problem with!!!!!

cotto ahead of margarito is not biased? that the worse offense. not just because he lost but he was tko'd. clottey went the whole 12 with marg injured. dawson, donaire, pavlik are #1 in their division. and i rank pavlik's win over taylor higher then cotto's win over mosley. you pushed raffy to far down after a close loss, but keep cotto ahead of someone he took a knee to?dawson has done enough.

[warp1432]

1. Pacquiao
2. Marquez
3. Calzaghe
4. Hopkins
5. Vazquez
6. Margarito
7. Rafael Marquez
8. Vic Darchinyan
9. Ivan Calderon
10. Ricky Hatton
11. Paul Williams
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Nonito Donaire
14. Cristian Mijares
15. Kelly Pavlik
16. Nate Campbell
17. Wladimir Klitchsko
18. Arthur Abraham
19. Hozumi Hasegawa
20. Chad Dawson

Hmmm....Sounds about right. I have Williams ranked over Cotto because that's how it should be for now. If Williams is ahead of Cotto in the welterweight ratings, he should be pound for pound too.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

cotto ahead of margarito is not biased? that the worse offense. not just because he lost but he was tko'd. clottey went the whole 12 with marg injured. dawson, donaire, pavlik are #1 in their division. and i rank pavlik's win over taylor higher then cotto's win over mosley. you pushed raffy to far down after a close loss, but keep cotto ahead of someone he took a knee to?dawson has done enough.

P4P are about quality wins and good resume and none of the above have better wins or better resume than Cotto. Well maybe Margarito edges him in Quality wins lately, but the rest dont come near cotto!!!!!!

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Hmmm....Sounds about right. I have Williams ranked over Cotto because that's how it should be for now. If Williams is ahead of Cotto in the welterweight ratings, he should be pound for pound too.

Williams by any means should be ahead of Cotto in the P4P list. What the hell have Williams done compare to Cotto, besides Beating Margarito? Like I already post P4P is about quality wins and resume. And Williams doesnt have more Quality wins than Cotto nor better resume!!!!!!