Who have the better Overall resume Cotto or Margarito?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

i think cotto has a better resume...but only because he was molded to be a draw...tony had a bit of a different path...i would like to see how cotto would do against clottey, williams and cintron...

I will like to see Margarito Winning against a top guy at another Weight!!!!

[Dynamite Kid]

i think cotto has a better resume...but only because he was molded to be a draw...tony had a bit of a different path...i would like to see how cotto would do against clottey, williams and cintron...

well could not have faired much worse cause Clottey gave him a Boxing lesson untill he broke his hand and he lost to Williams

[Mr. Fantastic]

Lujan is nothing, Randall was worthless and he has not fought Mosley yet!! Giving him Randall, is like giving Leonard to Camacho, because leonard is a big name,Makes no sense!!!

Lujan was top 10 Welter when he fought Margarito. Either way, Randall is still a name.

If that is the case then why did you put Bazan & Maussa on Cotto's list???? Bazan is shot and lost to an up an coming Alvarado, lets not forget he was on his way out when he faced Cotto. Maussa is shot, lost to Victor Ortiz.

Lujan on the other hand has been winning, even if its against an old Castillo.

[Mr. Fantastic]

I will like to see Margarito Winning against a top guy at another Weight!!!!

He did, its called home cooking against Santos.

[bobbito]

I'm gonna have to go with Cotto on this.

Margarito has fought,
Diaz,Kamau, Santos, Martinez,Kyvelos, Clottey ,Cintron,Williams,cotto

Cotto have fought,
Bazan ,Maussa, Corley,Bailey,N´Dou,Torres,Malignnaggi,Quintana, Judah,Molsey,Margarito

alos you gotta keep in mind...cotto was not a natural 140 pounder...the only real welters he's fought are tony and quintana...i think 147 suites him better...thats why i wanna see how he does with clottey, williams and cintron

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Lujan was top 10 Welter when he fought Margarito. Either way, Randall is still a name.

If that is the case then why did you put Bazan & Maussa on Cotto's list???? Bazan is shot and lost to an up an coming Alvarado, lets not forget he was on his way out when he faced Cotto. Maussa is shot, lost to Victor Ortiz.

Lujan on the other hand has been winning, even if its against an old Castillo.

Bazan was still tough as nails and Bazan had 45 fights at the time while Cotto had 14 and Maussa is a former world Champ, and at the time Cotto fought him he was undefeted.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

He did, its called home cooking against Santos.

Nope, at the time of the stopage, santos was ahead. The fight coulded continue, but it didnt!!!!!! So Santos Won!

[bobbito]

well could not have faired much worse cause Clottey gave him a Boxing lesson untill he broke his hand and he lost to Williams

i agree...but that wasnt tonys fault...if your hands give out on you, to me its the same thing as having a weak chin...you need your hands to hold up just as much as you need your chin to...i think cotto vs clottey woud be good...cotto is a more skilled boxer than tony...i think it would be a dope fight...

[Mr. Fantastic]

Bazan was still tough as nails and Bazan had 45 fights at the time while Cotto had 14 and Maussa is a former world Champ, and at the time Cotto fought him he was undefeted and Cotto.

But yet you can't count Lujan when he was a top 10 Welter or Randall??? Comon now guy. Margarito didn't know what he knows now when he faced Randall, who is a tough veteran who has a win against JCC.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Nope, at the time of the stopage, santos was ahead. The fight coulded continue, but it didnt!!!!!! So Santos Won!

BY??? A fight due to a cut right??? Would you call that a real win??? If the cut was so bad why didn't they stopped it earlier??