The most Overrated/underrated Trainer is....

**Sage84** · 11-23-2008, 11:58 AM

Haha, second i read the title of this thread i knew what u were gonna say....

McGirt isnt overrated and Floyd Sr seriously isnt underrated, hes known as one of the best in the sport!

**ACHlLLES** · 11-23-2008, 11:58 AM

Who is overrating McGirt? When is the last time one of his fighters won? It probably was his son, and McGirt hand picks those fights and doesn't really let his son go against anyone who would ever give him trouble... And he still has one loss.

**The Surgeon** · 11-23-2008, 12:15 PM

Floyd Mayweather Snr for me is the most over rated ESPECIALLY by himself!
Adam Booth is the most under rated

**boxaholic** · 11-23-2008, 12:17 PM

Originally posted by MacChamp

Who is overrating McGirt? When is the last time one of his fighters won? It probably was his son, and McGirt hand picks those fights and doesn't really let his son go against anyone who would ever give him trouble... And he still has one loss.

Exactly. Mcgirt has had what champ. His biggest superstar was Gatti and he didn't teach him much. His son is a average fighter at best and for him to throw in the towel when he knows how much it means to Paulie to go 12 rounds regardless. If he was going to throw in the towel he should have told Paulie in the corner before the 11th round that if he wasn't more active he would stop the fight.

Mayweather Sr. is so good that he made Ricky Hatton look like a boxer. Yes I said it. Before Mayweather Sr. Hatton was a brawler that would hit and hold. He actualy boxed last night and Paulie was the one holding.

**boxaholic** · 11-23-2008, 12:20 PM

Originally posted by The Surgeon

Floyd Mayweather Snr for me is the most over rated ESPECIALLY by himself!
Adam Booth is the most under rated

By himself yeah because he claims he is the greatest of all time. Otherwise he is underrated on this board. Some people have Nacho Bernstien ahead of him LOL. THe Roach vs Mayweather Sr. comparison is competitive. But no other trainer is in that trainer class.

**The Surgeon** · 11-23-2008, 12:21 PM

Originally posted by boxaholic

Exactly. Mcgirt has had what champ. His biggest superstar was Gatti and he didn't teach him much. His son is a average fighter at best and for him to throw in the towel when he knows how much it means to Paulie to go 12 rounds regardless. If he was going to throw in the towel he should have told Paulie in the corner before the 11th round that if he wasn't more active he would stop the fight.

He did tell him and warn him but i thought it was just an effort to get him going i didnt think he was serious, he didnt really emphasize it

**The Surgeon** · 11-23-2008, 12:23 PM

Originally posted by boxaholic

By himself yeah because he claims he is the greatest of all time. Otherwise he is underrated on this board. Some people have Nacho Bernstien ahead of him LOL. THe Roach vs Mayweather Sr. comparison is competitive. But no other trainer is in that trainer class.

I really dont think he's up to snuff. Ive heard alot of people really rating the guy some think he is the sports best today

**Pullcounter** · 11-23-2008, 12:25 PM

Originally posted by boxaholic

For overrated it has to be Buddy Mgdirt and for underrated it must be Mayweather Sr.

nacho is underrated. roach might be overrated.

floyd sr is just promoting himself. he needs to make money somehow.

**boxaholic** · 11-23-2008, 12:27 PM

Originally posted by Pullcounter

nacho is underrated. roach might be overrated.

floyd sr is just promoting himself. he needs to make money somehow.

Besides the Marquez brothers what has he done. Roach is fading away because of his disease but he is still way better than Nacho.

The most Overrated/underrated Trainer is....