If Paulie loses and breaks his hand again...

[Sage84]

Should HE retire? I remember him saying no too long after his last fight that if he breaks his hand another couple of times then that is it for him, he would retire cos it just cant be repaired......I m wondering if another loss at this stage as well as a broken hand would bring that forward for him...it ll be a long way back for both fighters if they lose.

Everyone seems to agree Hatton should retire if he loses, but what about an injured Paulie?..

[sylvestersweet]

If Malignaggi breaks his hand again and loses, he should definitely retire. If he loses and doesn't break his hand he's still young so he can still fight.
If Hatton loses he should retire because he obviously has nothing left if he loses to this guy.

[Jexy55]

If he loses and breaks his hand BUT puts on a show of heart and courage like the Cotto performance, then perhaps he has a couple more big fights and people would be interested.

If he loses, breaks his hand and has a poor performance, then retire. 3 poor performances on the trot and 2 straight fights breaking your hand....then yeah

[The Gully Gad]

No he shouldnt retire..
Joe calzaghe can break his hand from just having a wank