Who's more overatted Margarito or Calzaghe??

[El Dominicano]

After the Pac/DLH fight he can.
If Pac loses, I think Cal deserves that #1 spot.

Regardless, isn't Pac STILL the more accomplished fighter? Why would a lose bring him down?

[WLAD_OWNS]

Calzaghe came to America and humuliated 2 American legends!!!

[Mr. Fantastic]

no Marquez is still there ahead of Calzaghe...I think he beat Pac twice anyways

I understand where you coming from. At first I thought Pac won the 2nd time then rewatched the fight(sorry I was drunk the night of the fight) and honestly believe Marquez won. I know it sucks, but a win is a win, even if its controversial.

[Flawless 2]

How old is Hopkins??? Yet he knocked down Calzaghe and has a case he won the fight

[El Dominicano]

Calzaghe came to America and humuliated 2 American legends!!!

Yes he beat a SHOT RJJ and humuliated? Just as long as you aren't talkin about the B-Hop fight lol

[Mr. Fantastic]

Regardless, isn't Pac STILL the more accomplished fighter? Why would a lose bring him down?

Yes he is, I won't deny that. Calzaghe hasn't lost & I don't think he will, trust me I'm not a fan of his, just saying. Besides, he did make Roy Jones look really really bad(I was going for RJ btw). Don't also forget that Cal has made numerous defenses and has been a champion for years, even if its in Europe. Can't discredit any of that.

[WhoreUs]

Calzaghe came to America and humuliated 2 American legends!!!

wladdie...i don't know much about joe but he started fighting in 1993 right?

how come it took him 'til this year to fight in the u.s.?

[El Dominicano]

I understand where you coming from. At first I thought Pac won the 2nd time then rewatched the fight(sorry I was drunk the night of the fight) and honestly believe Marquez won. I know it sucks, but a win is a win, even if its controversial.

That is very hard to accpet...

Where would Pernell be ranked had he gotten the U.D against JCC and DLH? Would have been a BIG VERY BIG difference

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

Both are overrated anyway!!!

[El Dominicano]

Yes he is, I won't deny that. Calzaghe hasn't lost & I don't think he will, trust me I'm not a fan of his, just saying. Besides, he did make Roy Jones look really really bad(I was going for RJ btw). Don't also forget that Cal has made numerous defenses and has been a champion for years, even if its in Europe. Can't discredit any of that.

Notable wins

Lacy = BUM
Kessler = Unproven
B-Hop past it and I didn't think he won
RJJ shot...

I can't even go as far as to respect him...You can hate someone and still respect him but

His resume deserves to be "peeleft: at.