Most Dominant Fighters of Past 5 Years

[Newyorkknicks07]

Mayweather. Undefeated, and while Cotto or Margarito might have beaten him, they never got the chance, and as much as i dislike the guy, got to give him his credit. Out of the choices in the poll, i guess i'd have to say Calzaghe. As much as i'd like to have seen him (has he announced his retirement yet?) fight higher competition, he beat who he fought, and wins over Hopkins and Lacy look good on his resume.

[Johnny Rebel]

Joe Calzaghe no doubt!

[RichCCFC]

Mayweather. Undefeated, and while Cotto or Margarito might have beaten him, they never got the chance, and as much as i dislike the guy, got to give him his credit.

Your p4p list is ****ed up.

[Wiley Hyena]

Mayweather. Undefeated, and while Cotto or Margarito might have beaten him, they never got the chance, and as much as i dislike the guy, got to give him his credit. Out of the choices in the poll, i guess i'd have to say Calzaghe. As much as i'd like to have seen him (has he announced his retirement yet?) fight higher competition, he beat who he fought, and wins over Hopkins and Lacy look good on his resume.

Mayweather was good, but he played dodge ball and fought a soft schedule. I'll give him a pass for dodging Tszu early on, but he cannot be forgiven for dodging Margarito and Cotto later on. History will, and is, judging him accordingly. He wanted to be the next Ray Robinson, but he ended up the next Ray Mancini. Fun but ultimately disappointing.