Oscar had a bigger size advantage vs. Floyd than vs. Manny

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • tito yuca
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jul 2006
    • 1843
    • 237
    • 233
    • 8,377

    #1

    Oscar had a bigger size advantage vs. Floyd than vs. Manny

    People criticize Floyd so much, they don't even want to give him credit for beating Oscar. However, everyone is saying Oscar will brutally KO Manny because of the size difference, so if Manny wins, he will be universally cheered.

    What these people don't realize is that the weight disparity between Oscar and Manny will be LESS than it was between Oscar and Floyd when they fought.

    Oscar weighed in at 154 and Floyd at 150, yet at fight night Oscar was 167 and Floyd 148. This is a NINETEEN pound weight advantage for Oscar. Roach has said Manny will weigh in about 140 and weigh 145 on fight night. Having to weigh-in at 147 vs. Manny means Oscar will be, at most, 160 on fight night. This will be a FIFTEEN pound weight advantage for Oscar.

    Manny weighed 144 for his fights at 130, so this show how big he really is because he needs to drain himself a lot to make weight. Floyd rarely put on more than 5 pounds on fight night, he even LOST 2 when he fought Oscar.

    What I love about this is that by saying how Manny will get brutally KO'd, the haters are giving Floyd credit without realizing it, because the fact that everyone gave Floyd a much better chance than they are giving Manny shows that they do recognize Floyd has superior skills.

    Oscar has a 19-pound advantage on Floyd (who is P4P #1) at the time, and if Floyd beats him he just beat an old man. Oscar has a 15-pound weight advantage on Manny (who is P4P #1), but he is gonna brutally KO him in 5 because of the size difference. Isn't this ironic?
  • MANGLER
    Sex Tape Flop Artist
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Feb 2008
    • 30142
    • 1,705
    • 2,355
    • 46,598

    #2
    How anyone can defend the whole DLH bein bigger than Pac **** is ridiculous.

    Comment

    • Thread Stealer
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Sep 2007
      • 9657
      • 439
      • 102
      • 17,804

      #3
      Originally posted by tito yuca
      People criticize Floyd so much, they don't even want to give him credit for beating Oscar. However, everyone is saying Oscar will brutally KO Manny because of the size difference, so if Manny wins, he will be universally cheered.

      What these people don't realize is that the weight disparity between Oscar and Manny will be LESS than it was between Oscar and Floyd when they fought.

      Oscar weighed in at 154 and Floyd at 150, yet at fight night Oscar was 167 and Floyd 148. This is a NINETEEN pound weight advantage for Oscar. Roach has said Manny will weigh in about 140 and weigh 145 on fight night. Having to weigh-in at 147 vs. Manny means Oscar will be, at most, 160 on fight night. This will be a FIFTEEN pound weight advantage for Oscar.

      Manny weighed 144 for his fights at 130, so this show how big he really is because he needs to drain himself a lot to make weight. Floyd rarely put on more than 5 pounds on fight night, he even LOST 2 when he fought Oscar.

      What I love about this is that by saying how Manny will get brutally KO'd, the haters are giving Floyd credit without realizing it, because the fact that everyone gave Floyd a much better chance than they are giving Manny shows that they do recognize Floyd has superior skills.

      Oscar has a 19-pound advantage on Floyd (who is P4P #1) at the time, and if Floyd beats him he just beat an old man. Oscar has a 15-pound weight advantage on Manny (who is P4P #1), but he is gonna brutally KO him in 5 because of the size difference. Isn't this ironic?
      Where did you get the figures for their fight night weights? All I remember is Mayweather saying he weighed 148. I don't know if they were weighed unofficially on fight night, I know HBO didn't release them, nor did they do it for Cotto-Mosley and PBF-Hatton.

      Comment

      • Ch@mpBox@PR
        Banned
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Feb 2008
        • 21432
        • 432
        • 279
        • 22,261

        #4
        Oscar started at 130
        Floyd started at 130
        Pacquiao started at 108

        Also Floyd is 5'8" and Many 5"6". So how Oscar had a bigger size advantage against Floyd?
        Last edited by Ch@mpBox@PR; 11-14-2008, 09:55 PM.

        Comment

        • tito yuca
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Jul 2006
          • 1843
          • 237
          • 233
          • 8,377

          #5
          Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
          Oscar started at 130
          Floyd started at 130
          Pacquiao started at 108

          Also Floyd is 5'8" and Many 5"6". So how Oscar had a bigger size advantage against Floyd?
          Read my post first, then ask questions.

          Comment

          • Jose Rizal
            Kilusang Kontra Kupal
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jan 2005
            • 1503
            • 58
            • 6
            • 7,925

            #6
            According to Manny on ESPN he weighed only 98 pounds in his first fight. He had to put metal in is pockets to actually "make weight."

            Comment

            • AceNguyen
              Interim Champion
              Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
              • Mar 2008
              • 605
              • 25
              • 4
              • 6,704

              #7
              Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
              Oscar started at 130
              Floyd started at 130
              Pacquiao started at 108

              Also Floyd is 5'8" and Many 5"6". So how Oscar had a bigger size advantage against Floyd?
              Floyd was also 108 in the amateurs at the age when Pac turned pro, Pac happened to start at a much younger age then both guys hence why he's moved up so many weights. I would say that Floyd's best weight is 140, Pac's best weight is 135 (not a huge difference).

              Comment

              • Ch@mpBox@PR
                Banned
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Feb 2008
                • 21432
                • 432
                • 279
                • 22,261

                #8
                Originally posted by tito yuca
                Read my post first, then ask questions.
                Well you said size advantage, so you have to count weight, height and reach. And let say your theory is correct and Oscar just outweights Pac by 15lbs, still the height difference will be 4 and 1/2 inches and 6 inches in reach. So in overall Oscars size advantage over Pac is more than the one in the Floyd fight!!!!!

                Comment

                • Ch@mpBox@PR
                  Banned
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Feb 2008
                  • 21432
                  • 432
                  • 279
                  • 22,261

                  #9
                  Originally posted by AceNguyen
                  Floyd was also 108 in the amateurs at the age when Pac turned pro, Pac happened to start at a much younger age then both guys hence why he's moved up so many weights. I would say that Floyd's best weight is 140, Pac's best weight is 135 (not a huge difference).
                  I think Floyds best weight was 135 and Pac 130. Pac hasnt being long enough at 135 to say thats his best weight!!!

                  Comment

                  • Bea5T
                    Undisputed Champion
                    • Sep 2007
                    • 1718
                    • 61
                    • 16
                    • 7,983

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Ch@mpBox@PR
                    Oscar started at 130
                    Floyd started at 130
                    Pacquiao started at 108

                    Also Floyd is 5'8" and Many 5"6". So how Oscar had a bigger size advantage against Floyd?
                    floyd was 108 when he was 16

                    same as pac

                    not too mention pbf - DLH fight was at 154

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP