Rank the top 5 light heavyweights?

[The Hammer]

How would you rank the top five current light heavyweights?

1. Calzaghe
2. Hopkins
3. Johnson
4. Erdei
5. Dawson

In my opinion, Johnson defeated Dawson, so I rank him higher.

[Testdead]

1.Calzaghe
2.Hopkins
3.dawson

















4. Who gives a ****
5. as above

[conor026]

Calzaghe
Hopkins
Dawson
Johnson
Jones

Calzaghe and hopkins, no explanations needed
I had dawson over johnson and dawson looked impressive against tarver
I have jones at 5 because the only other two guys i would put at 5 are
woods or tarver, and i think jones would beat tarver or woods at the moment
I don't rate erdei, i think he is very protected, hasn't fought any of the other
top guys

[WhoreUs]

1. joe calzaghe
2. pride of wales
3. the italian dragon
4. roy jones jr. (the prime version from 2008)
5. bernard hopkins (the 43 yr. old version)

joe calzaghe is the greatest of all time!!!!!

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Calzaghe
Hopkins
Dawson
Johnson
Jones

Calzaghe and hopkins, no explanations needed
I had dawson over johnson and dawson looked impressive against tarver
I have jones at 5 because the only other two guys i would put at 5 are
woods or tarver, and i think jones would beat tarver or woods at the moment
I don't rate erdei, i think he is very protected, hasn't fought any of the other
top guys

I agree with your rankings sir. At the moment I am banking on the fact that Calzaghe is that good and not that Jones was that bad. Call me sentimental or something. Johnson and Dawson are very clsoe and Tarver is right behind Jones. I have the same thought about Dawson as Calzaghe he was that good not that Tarver was that bad. I wouldn't mind seeing Hopkins fight Calzaghe again and see Tarver fight Jones again why not? Tarver Jones 4. Unfortunately this leaves Johnson and Dawson and wouldn't mind seeing Dawson beat Johnson more convincingly this time out....Lefty

[The Hammer]

1. joe calzaghe
2. pride of wales
3. the italian dragon
4. roy jones jr. (the prime version from 2008)
5. bernard hopkins (the 43 yr. old version)

joe calzaghe is the greatest of all time!!!!!

Your first three are good choices!

[Randall_Hopkirk]

I'd put Tarver, Woods and even Diaconu ahead of Erdei, he may hold a world title but he has the resume of a prospect.

[sitai]

calzaghe
dawson
hopkins
johnson
tarver

[WhoreUs]

Your first three are good choices!

i knew you'd agree.

you and _ricky_ need to tell joe to fight my boy glen.

win or lose i want glengoffe to get a nice paycheck.

plus you know glen will fight him in wales. don't know about bernard or chad.

[The Hammer]

i knew you'd agree.

you and _ricky_ need to tell joe to fight my boy glen.

win or lose i want glengoffe to get a nice paycheck.

plus you know glen will fight him in wales. don't know about bernard or chad.

I wouldn't mind seeing Johnson vs. Calzaghe, but only if you give Joe credit if he wins, and not overemphasize Glenn's age.