rank these Superstars

[Dynamite Kid]

Here we go:

1)Jones
2)Hopkins
3)Lewis
4)Whitaker
5)Mayweather
6)Calzaghe
7)ODLH
8)Holyfield
9)Mosley
10)Toney

The top spot was a no brainer. I had to think long and hard where to place Calzaghe due to his credible wins like Hopkins and mainly Kessler. The Jones win was sweet but is almost void altogether.

i would be interested to know why you put Mosley above Toney

[Liaison]

1. Pernell Whittker
2. Roy Jones Jr
3. Evander Holyfield
4. Lennox Lewis
5. Floyd Mayweather
6. Oscar De La Hoya
7. Bernard Hopkins
8. Joe Calzaghe
9. James Toney
10. Shane Mosely

[S.G.]

1. Hopkins
2. Mayweather Jr.
3. Jones Jr.
4. Whitaker
5. Lewis
6. De La Hoya
7. Calzaghe
8. Holyfield
9. Toney
10. Mosley

...damn, that was hard!

[RichCCFC]

Very little in it.

[KESSLER]

This is really, really hard. Maybe something like this:

1. Bernard Hopkins
2. Oscar De La Hoya
3. Roy Jones Jr.
4. Pernell Whitaker
5. Joe Calzaghe
6. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
7. Lennox Lewis
8. James Toney
9. Evander Holyfield
10. Shane Mosley

[Kris Silver]

Jones
Hopkins
Mayweather
Whitaker
Calzaghe
ODLH
Lewis
Toney
Mosley
Holyfield

Very hard to do this and quite subjective mixed with objective is the best one can hope for. But I quite like this list, but bump Lennox ahead of ODL. and Holyfield ahead of Mosley.

[warp1432]

1. Whitaker
2. Jones
3. Hopkins
4. Lewis
5. Mayweather
6. Holyfield
7. De La Hoya
8. Calzaghe
9. Toney
10. Mosley

The only thing really hard was 5,6,7. It was pretty easy for that though. In terms of accomplishements you have a good case for Holyfield and De La Hoya being better then Mayweather. At the same time you can put him ahead of them too.