Put these in order of overall greatness........

[EL HANDSOME]

1.) Jones
2.) Hopkins
3.) Toney
4.) Calzaghe

I agree with this.

[Dan...]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe

They are all ATGs, I just think that the resumes of the preceding 3 trump Joe's. Add a win over Dawson and I would have to seriously consider lifting him ahead of James, as hard as that is for me to say.

[Silencers]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Calzaghe

[warp1432]

Hopkins, Jones, Calzaghe, Toney.

Toney would beat Calzaghe, but in terms of Accomplishments, Calzaghe > Toney.

Hopkins over Jones in terms over resume. Hopkins loses to Roy.

[WhoreUs]

160-175 this past era......

1. roy jones jr.
2. james toney
3. darius michalczewski
4. bernard hopkins
5. sven ottke
6. virgil hill
7. glengoffe johnson
8. antonio tarver
9. joe calzaghe
10. william joppy

[Tmb04]

Hopkins
Jones
Calzaghe
Toney

[Flawless 2]

Jones
Hopkins
Toney
Miguel Cotto
Calzaghe

[El Dominicano]

1. B-Hop
2. RJJ
3. Toney
4. Calzaghe

[ßringer]

Bernard Hopkins
Roy Jones
James Toney
Floyd Mayweather (Can't leave him out)
Joe Calzaghe

The list switches up a bit when you add in some of the other greats of the last 15 years like Oscar, Shane, Pernell, Barrera, Morales, etc....

Pac should probably be on this list too. Well, no "probably" about it.

[The_Italian]

Jones
Hopkins
Calzaghe
Toney