Who is GREATER?

[RichCCFC]

Bernard Hopkins or Floyd Mayweather

[Dan...]

That is a pretty tough one.

[larryx]

joe calzaghe

[rizkybizness]

sven ottke

[krispy kreme]

Hopkins, greater legacy. Overall I would say Floyd is maybe the more complete fighter, but Hopkins has accomplished a bit more.

[Sox8055]

Smokin Joe beats both of these tomato cans....

[RichCCFC]

Hopkins, greater legacy. Overall I would say Floyd is maybe the more complete fighter, but Hopkins has accomplished a bit more.

What makes his legacy better?

[Benny Leonard]

MAYWETHER.

Floyd had the better boxing ability and athletic ability to beat every type of style, while Hopkins, would always lose to someone like Roy.


And I hate to keep saying it because Hopkins is from Philly, but he avoided Roy for a reason. When he moved up to LH and won the title, he beat a deflated Tarver, the same way Tarver beat a deflated Roy Jones Jr.

I give him credit for teaching Pavlik a lesson and the rest of his career when he fought actual Middle-weights...and not Tito and Oscar, even though the Tito win was very good.

[S.G.]

too tough to call... my head hurts thinking about it

[Wales08]

Eh.....id say Mayweather as he does have the complete package.