Would Darchinyan Be Top P4p Top10 Atlest?

**IwatchBoxing** · 11-10-2008, 06:26 AM

Hes the first at his weight divsion to unify three belts, if he beats Montiel he could be close.

**Dan...** · 11-10-2008, 06:27 AM

No.

He got KTFO a few fights ago by a non-elite guy. Beating a guy in the bottom half of the p4p list does not instantly get you on the p4p list in my view. I have him just inside the top 15 right now. He would get in the 10 if he beat Montiel or another top guy.

**FasTHarD** · 11-10-2008, 06:36 AM

Originally posted by danc1984

No.

He got KTFO a few fights ago by a non-elite guy. Beating a guy in the bottom half of the p4p list does not instantly get you on the p4p list in my view. I have him just inside the top 15 right now. He would get in the 10 if he beat Montiel or another top guy.

Margarito becomes p4p material when he beats Cotto.... Only Cotto no other and he lost 5 times.... Darchinyan is a long time flyweight division and he just unified the 115.. He lost only once to a good boxer and elite Donaire.. Don't tell me donaire is not elite lol... Darchinyan should be at top10 p4p right now...

**sjomcik** · 11-10-2008, 06:56 AM

I have heard rumors, that Vic vs Arce is almost signed....That's gona be great fight, I think Vic can take Arce by KO and then Montiel or rematch with Donair

**Flawless 2** · 11-10-2008, 06:58 AM

Originally posted by FasTHarD

Vic just KO one of the top p4p mijarez... Can he become a top p4p material? yes or no and why.... Margarito become P4P member when he KO Cotto....

Cotto Clottey and lost a close decision to Williams not too bad

**BlackHat** · 11-10-2008, 06:59 AM

Originally posted by sjomcik

I have heard rumors, that Vic vs Arce is almost signed....That's gona be great fight, I think Vic can take Arce by KO and then Montiel or rematch with Donair

you got proof? link please. I thought Top rank is working on Arce vs donaire.

**boxing_great** · 11-10-2008, 06:59 AM

I really don't think margarito belongs in the p4p list.
I feel as though he has beaten somebody much smaller than him, and he hasn't totally dominated the division.

While I picked him to beat Cotto, I don't think his skills are p4p material.

As for Vic, it's a toss up

**JOM'S** · 11-10-2008, 07:21 AM

imho depending where you put mijares p4p before the loss to vic determines where vic is now, when and if he beats montiel, definite consideration should be made...

Would Darchinyan Be Top P4p Top10 Atlest?