Is Calzaghe P4P #1?

[Pride Of Arkans]

Thats pretty disturbing that some people would put Calzaghe
over Pacquiao for beating a washed up Jones.

No he was already above him imo
he became number 1 by beating Hopkins

by the way you cannot give Pacquiao credit for fighting Oscar
he has to beat him to get respect and thats not gonna happen.

[MANGLER]

Hell no he ain't.

[daggum]

if calzaghe is 1 where do you put glen johnson and tarver who knocked him cold and didnt get knocked down in the process? lets try to make a little sense here nuthuggers.

[Pride Of Arkans]

Hey Daggum you ****head Joe is not number 1 for one fight
Look back at his whole career and no active fighter has done more
he is on a 46 fight winning streak which includes wins over Kessler, Hopkins and Jones.

[AztecWanker]

1. pac
2. jmm
3. joe
4. bhop

though casamayor was past his prime, he was still recognized as the LW champ and jmm stopped him. jones was a shell of himself and didnt even own a belt.

[Floyd Sinclair]

Calzaghes not even top 10

[Pride Of Arkans]

Calzaghes not even top 10

Get back to the back of the bus
I did not give you permission to talk ****.

[daggum]

Hey Daggum you ****head Joe is not number 1 for one fight
Look back at his whole career and no active fighter has done more
he is on a 46 fight winning streak which includes wins over Kessler, Hopkins and Jones.

beating jones means **** we established that. tarver and johnson would be on the list if it meant anything. a "win" over hopkins which was really a loss shouldn't move you up the list. beating kessler is good but hopkins beat pavlik who was actually on the list.

hopkins last wins tarver, winky , calzaghe and pavlik
calzaghes last wins, bika, manfredo, kessler, shot roy jones.

OH MY I WONDER WHO SHOULD BE HIGHER?

[BrooklynBomber]

Well, taking into an account that Pacman's best victories were against senior citizens and he really got his spot because Floy left the scene, not because he earned it and also taking into an account that if Manny and Joe were to fight in the same weight division Joe would be the top dog it is not a stretch to have him at one.

[kenso]

yea, as much as i like joe and think hes fantastic, he just cant be put above pac right now. pac is knocking people the **** out, joe is just outclassing them.