Ive yet to hear how this win means ANYTHING from Calzaghe fans.

[Ray*]

Apart from Tunney who is ******ed to say the least i dont think calzaghe beating RJJ meant alot in terms of legacy.

[FloydsEra]

I like Joe and I don't think this win means a whole lot. It was nice the way Joe came back after Roy dropped him, but we already knew Joe had heart.

[Ray*]

How can Pacquiao be rated as the number 1 p4p ?
Barrera and Morales are just as washed up as Hopkins and Jones
then Pacquiao beat David Diaz who's hardly a great fighter.

What young unbeaten champions has Pacquiao beaten
and what divisions has he dominated ?

I like Pacquiao but Calzaghe has done more
and he didnt get stopped twice in his own backyard either.

The thing is pacman and calzaghe both have a similar resume, But Joe beat younger fighters like Lacy and Kessler and pacman hasnt been able to do the same.

[BlackHat]

Apart from Tunney who is ******ed to say the least i dont think calzaghe beating RJJ meant alot in terms of legacy.

$#@wN, ЯiZO, Adam1979, brian m, Casey2, Chunk, Dorian, Dr.Dre, GMitchell, Grand Champ, gunners, ianblake, JayWater39, leppard365, Lord13, louis24592, majestiC, markevo, Merseysideblood, Mrpedigree, Naps, revs1227, rich6666, Rookieboy, sarlick, sjomcik, Slugger_P4P, SpArKeD-CoLd, Tony628, TonyJ, Tunney, VERSATILE2K9, WLAD_OWNS, Zmlacksz, _Ricky_, ~Ironside

[S.W.F.C]

The worst Im hearing is that joe calzaghe could have beaten a prime roy which is reduculus.

Why the hell is it ridiculous ?
Once inside the ring anything can happen, there is no pre determined pattern. Roy in his prime isn't a god, isn't invincible.

He was an amazing fighter yes, one of the greatest but everyone saying Roy would dance around Joe, slaughter Joe are talking out of there arse.

It only takes a lapse of concentration from a fighter and their in trouble, one split second taking your eye off the ball and that's it, the other guy could land clean with a hammering shot and its good night.

[micky_knox]

Well it obviously means something Roy fans because they just cant stop talking about it

[Slugger_P4P]

I'm a huge Calzaghe fan...was delighted he picked up wins over Jones and Hopkins, however, if Jones Jr. was in his prime then i fully believe that Calzaghe would not have beaten him. A Roy in his prime would have ended Calzaghe or anyone else for that matter after the knockdown.
In terms of Calzaghe's career, i feel he's had a good one but not an excellent one. I give him credit for the demolition of Jeff Lacy and his wins over Kessler and Hopkins, though I feel Bernard did beat him. I would have liked to see Calzaghe get in the ring with Carl Froch sometime before he called it a day and that will never happen, a younger fighter, big hitter, someone who would have been more of a challenge than a 39 year old past his best Jones Jr, however, give Roy credit, he put up a good show.
I personally don't see Calzaghe retiring just yet. Maybe 1 more fight at the Millenium Stadium but the question is who? I would like to see a Hopkins rematch, especially after what he did to Pavlik but Calzaghe is dismissing any rematches...wonder why!