Pacquiao or Calzaghe : Who is the real senior citizen killer?

[ßringer]

Pac has dominant wins over shot versions of Erik Morales and marco Antonio Barrera.

Calzaghe has a dominant win over a shot Roy Jones and a SD over a past prime Hopkins.

Who's the ultimate senior citizen killer?

There can be only one!



vs.

[WhoreUs]

Pac has dominant wins over shot versions of Erik Morales and marco Antonio Barrera.

Calzaghe has a dominant win over a shot Roy Jones and a SD over a past prime Hopkins.

Who's the ultimate senior citizen killer?

There can be only one!



vs.

if hopkins is considered past prime and not shot...... barrera shouldn't be considered shot. barrera should be considered a tad bit past prime.

roy was on the same level of shot as erik in the 3rd pac fight but i think erik had more in the tank when he lost in the 2nd fight.

[ßringer]

if hopkins is considered past prime and not shot...... barrera shouldn't be considered shot. barrera should be considered a tad bit past prime.

roy was on the same level of shot as erik in the 3rd pac fight but i think erik had more in the tank when he lost in the 2nd fight.

I agree with that.

Jones = Morales
Barrera = Hopkins

In terms of Jones and Morales both being completely shot (Erik had a little juice left though in the 2nd bout), and in terms of Hopkins and Barrer abeing removed from their prime but not entirely shot either.

[WhoreUs]

I agree with that.

Jones = Morales
Barrera = Hopkins

In terms of Jones and Morales both being completely shot (Erik had a little juice left though in the 2nd bout), and in terms of Hopkins and Barrer abeing removed from their prime but not entirely shot either.

can we just go off of age?

late 20's and early 30's sound a lot better than late 30's early 40's.

[ßringer]

can we just go off of age?

late 20's and early 30's sound a lot better than late 30's early 40's.

So you're saying Joe is the ultimate senior citizen annihilator because his prey is far older than Pac's?