who was more shot Jones against Calz or Tyson v Lewis ?

[Dynamite Kid]

who was more shot Jones against Calz or Tyson v Lewis ?i say Jones based on the fact i think Lewis would beat any version of Tyson where as Joe would get outclassed against Jones in his prime

[daggum]

roy without a doubt. he had nothing and still almost ko'd the fraud. lewis at least got a helpless tyson out of there. calzaghe just bounced around for 12 rounds slapping like crazy.

[kenso]

DEFINITELY tyson, not even close.......

[TheGreatA]

Both had lost a lot, Tyson maybe more as far as speed, stamina and reflexes go, but a big puncher with a good chin like Tyson is always a threat.

Jones didn't really have anything left after a couple of rounds.

Tyson's win over Golota was solid (better than Roy's recent wins I would say) although Golota is an unpredictable fighter.

To be honest comparing heavyweights to the lower weight classes is always difficult. Even a shot heavyweight can still end the fight with one punch.

[Dynamite Kid]

Both had lost a lot, Tyson maybe more as far as speed, stamina and reflexes go, but a big puncher with a good chin like Tyson is always a threat.

Jones didn't really have anything left after a couple of rounds.

Tyson's win over Golota was solid (better than Roy's recent wins I would say) although Golota is an unpredictable fighter.

my biggest critcism for Tyson that fought Lewis was his lack of footspeed he used to have tremendous footspeed that allowed him to close the range quickly and he needed that big time against Lenny and it was gone

[-Boxzilla-]

thats a good question . . . mmm . . . i would go with tyson.