If Roy wins I don't think his all time status grows that much

[Check]

You would think if a 39 year old man beats a 45-0 fighter his HOF status would skyrocket but I don't think it does. Even though Calzaghe has been dominate during his reign as champion at SMW he is not considered a top 50 fighter all time. Roy win or lose is a top 50 but if he wins I doubt it really does anything for his place in history. A loss for Joe would really hurt Joe a lot though. Maybe drop him from a top 75 fighter to maybe a top 150.

[MANGLER]

Roy's got a legacy to be proud of wit or without a win over Joe, but it obviously can't hurt him to win. Cats who hate Joe C won't give Roy props if he wins, but it would be one of his more impressive victories, given the time in his career the fight is takin palce.

[Chr0nic]

**** man, have you seen calzaghe's record?.. beating that guy would'nt hurt any mans resume

[Mr. Philadel]

This would be one of Roy's biggest wins. His status WOULD grow!