is vic a top ten p4p fighter now?????

[Sox8055]

By the rules of the Ring Mag, he should be....

[Alec900]

if margarito rises to p4p list by beating cotto then vic should do the same by beating mijares

[moochi]

if margarito rises to p4p list by beating cotto then vic should do the same by beating mijares

not to mention he KO'd one of the all time greats in Irene Pacheco...

ppl just hate Vic, but his record is up there with a very polished resume- yes he has one blemish, how many fighters don't have a blemish??

Vic definitely a top P4P-er.

[Silencers]

I'm not sure, the Donaire loss is still fresh in my mind.

[miron_lang]

i sure think so

seriously?

Where do you have Nonito then?

[ragingvic]

Well Paul Williams isnt in the top 10, but Margarito is. Right or wrong, if we are going to follow these rules then vic should be in the top 10 even with the loss to donaire.

[-Swizzy-]

it would be illogical if he wasn't top 10 cuz he didn't just beat a p4p fighter, but totally dominate and embarass a #7 ranked p4p fighter. so if he doesn't make atleast 10th I would like to know the explanation from Ring. it would be a big injustice if he doesn't make the ranking.

[STEELHEAD]

had mijares ranked in my p4p list so have to drop mijares and replace with the improved darchinyan!

[DiegoFuego]

Margarito, Pavlik, now Darchinyan in the p4p list? This sport is ****ed beyond belief

[We want Floyd]

Margarito, Pavlik, now Darchinyan in the p4p list? This sport is ****ed beyond belief

I agree, but with the current state of boxing who would have in place of Margarita, Pav, and Darch?