At this point who is the better overall fighter Anthony Mudine Or Paulie Malignaggi?

[Southpaw16BF]

Both have pretty similar styles, both are showmen both have been world champions.Both have never been pound for pounders.
Mudine holds win over Danny Green,Sam Solimanx3,Antwun Echols,Nader Hamdan.
Malignaggi holds wins over Lovemore N'doux2,Edner Cherry,Herman Ngoudjo.

Both Fighters can look great at times etc Mallignaggi/N'Dou1 Mudine/Green and both can look very dodgey at times Malignaggi/Ngoudjo Mudine/Sam Soliman 3. Both have losses to the big gun fighters etc Kessler/Cotto. And sometimes i get the feelin both fighters feel better than they actual are.

So who in your mind is the better out of the two?

[Kesslerfan#1]

Both have pretty similar styles, both are showmen both have been world champions.Both have never been pound for pounders.
Mudine holds win over Danny Green,Sam Solimanx3,Antwun Echols,Nader Hamdan.
Malignaggi holds wins over Lovemore N'doux2,Edner Cherry,Herman Ngoudjo.

Both Fighters can look great at times etc Mallignaggi/N'Dou1 Mudine/Green and both can look very dodgey at times Malignaggi/Ngoudjo Mudine/Sam Soliman 3. Both have losses to the big gun fighters etc Kessler/Cotto. And sometimes i get the feelin both fighters feel better than they actual are.

So who in your mind is the better out of the two?

Who is Anthony MUDINE YA JACKASS!!!

[boxasmash]

about the same

[Southpaw16BF]

Who is Anthony MUDINE YA JACKASS!!!

A former world champion, who are you?

[Southpaw16BF]

Any more thoughts?

[Zerwas1]

Mundine is the better man, but his choice of opponents very very weak lately

[TheManchine]

Mundine is a better fighter imo, although he doesnt seem to have much ambition

isnt he trying to get a rematch with Green a guy he already beat?

i think he is happy to stay at home making good money fighting needless rematches

[Southpaw16BF]

Yeah agreed, Mudine's really needs to step up his quality in opponets.

[-Boxzilla-]

ever since cotto/malignaggi i've always had respect for malignaggi. i would say him because of quality of opposition, he's been active with the better guys in his weight class and is going to fight the #1 in the weight class being hatton . . . and i hope he wins.