BBC's new P4P list

[Flab]

Williams is one of the top ten p4pounders in the sport.

Danny? Yes, he should be on that list, I agree.

[C.Y.]

that list is sorry
pavlik shouldnt be on this list, cotto is too high on the list, ricky hatton also shouldnt be there.. chad dawson should be on the list and bhop should be higher up on the list at either 3 or 4

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

That list is garbage. Cotto and margarito are too high and Williams and Hatton should not be in the list. And B-Hop needs to be at #3 with out a doubt.

[toluco]

i agree list is garbage
where is cristian mijares he is way better than ricky hatton
theyre brit biased i wonder why they didnt put haye in there

[Flab]

i agree list is garbage
where is cristian mijares he is way better than ricky hatton
theyre brit biased i wonder why they didnt put haye in there

ElGran still banned?

[toluco]

ElGran still banned?

yeah i dont think he is ever coming back

[Flab]

yeah i dont think he is ever coming back

**** man, tough break.

[HandSpeed303]

was cotto on the p4p list when margarito beat him?
was mosley on the p4p list when cotto beat him?

i don't agree with the list, but to answer the question you asked, yes cotto was on the list when margo beat him...he was #5(i think).

[The_Italian]

i agree with that list for the most part...

paul williams and hatton arent on it...they are lower than top 10...they are between top 11 and 20 in my opinion.

other than that this list is great.

[Fearless BONG]

Now this is a bad list! What does everyone think??:

1. Manny Pacquiao - Lightweight
Philippines (47-3-2, 35KOs)
The all-action Pacquiao became a four-weight world champion by destroying David Diaz to claim the WBC lightweight title and will now fight Oscar de la Hoya in December.

2. Joe Calzaghe - Super-middleweight
Wales (45-0, 32KOs)
Calzaghe outpointed Bernard Hopkins on his US and light-heavyweight debut and says he will retire after his fight with the great Roy Jones Jr in New York on 8 November.

3. Juan Manuel Marquez - Lightweight
Mexico (49-4-1, 36KOs)
Marquez became the first man to stop Cuba's Joel Casamayor in his first fight at lightweight and will now chase a third bout with Manny Pacquiao.

4. Antonio Margarito - Welterweight
Mexico (37-5, 27KOs)
Margarito pipped Miguel Cotto in a thrilling match-up and proved he has perhaps the best chin in the sport. Margarito defends against Joshua Clottey next.

5. Miguel Cotto - Welterweight
Puerto Rico (32-1, 26KOs)
Cotto finally met his match against Antonio Margarito in a classic encounter, but lost little of his lustre in doing so and is young enough to rise to the top again.

6. Bernard Hopkins - Light-heavyweight
United States (49 wins, 5 losses, 1 draws, 32KOs)
Hopkins showed he still has plenty to offer with his schooling of the upstart Kelly Pavlik in Atlantic City. Ironically, at the age of 43, he is running out of viable opponents.

7. Israel Vazquez - Super-bantamweight
Mexico (43-4, 31KOs)
Vazquez reclaimed his WBC belt from Rafael Marquez in August and nicked the rubber match in March. A relentless fighter with a vicious left hook.

8. Ricky Hatton - Light-welterweight
England (44-1, 31KOs)
Hatton defeated tough Mexican Juan Lazcano in his first fight since losing to Floyd Mayweather and should have enough to beat Paul Malignaggi in the autumn.

9. Paul Williams - Welterweight
United States (34-1, 25KOs)
Williams defeated Antonio Margarito in 2007 before losing to Carlos Quintana in February. Williams won the rematch and a second clash with Margarito is now a distinct possibility.

10. Kelly Pavlik - Middleweight
United States (34-1, 30KOs)
Pavlik was outclassed by the wily Bernard Hopkins in Atlantic City, but remains the WBC and WBO middleweight champion and will likely move back down.

I think this is much better baby
1. Manny Pacquiao - Lightweight
Philippines (47-3-2, 35KOs)
The all-action Pacquiao became a four-weight world champion by destroying David Diaz to claim the WBC lightweight title and will now fight Oscar de la Hoya in December.

2. Bernard Hopkins - Light-heavyweight
United States (49 wins, 5 losses, 1 draws, 32KOs)
Hopkins showed he still has plenty to offer with his schooling of the upstart Kelly Pavlik in Atlantic City. Ironically, at the age of 43, he is running out of viable opponents.

3. Joe Calzaghe - Super-middleweight
Wales (45-0, 32KOs)
Calzaghe outpointed Bernard Hopkins on his US and light-heavyweight debut and says he will retire after his fight with the great Roy Jones Jr in New York on 8 November.

4. Antonio Margarito - Welterweight
Mexico (37-5, 27KOs)
Margarito pipped Miguel Cotto in a thrilling match-up and proved he has perhaps the best chin in the sport. Margarito defends against Joshua Clottey next.

5. Kelly Pavlik - Middleweight
United States (34-1, 30KOs)
Pavlik was outclassed by the wily Bernard Hopkins in Atlantic City, but remains the WBC and WBO middleweight champion and will likely move back down.

6. Juan Manuel Marquez - Lightweight
Mexico (49-4-1, 36KOs)
Marquez became the first man to stop Cuba's Joel Casamayor in his first fight at lightweight and will now chase a third bout with Manny Pacquiao.


7. Miguel Cotto - Welterweight
Puerto Rico (32-1, 26KOs)
Cotto finally met his match against Antonio Margarito in a classic encounter, but lost little of his lustre in doing so and is young enough to rise to the top again.

8. Israel Vazquez - Super-bantamweight
Mexico (43-4, 31KOs)
Vazquez reclaimed his WBC belt from Rafael Marquez in August and nicked the rubber match in March. A relentless fighter with a vicious left hook.

9. Ricky Hatton - Light-welterweight
England (44-1, 31KOs)
Hatton defeated tough Mexican Juan Lazcano in his first fight since losing to Floyd Mayweather and should have enough to beat Paul Malignaggi in the autumn.

10. Paul Williams - Welterweight
United States (34-1, 25KOs)
Williams defeated Antonio Margarito in 2007 before losing to Carlos Quintana in February. Williams won the rematch and a second clash with Margarito is now a distinct possibility.