BBC's new P4P list

[bsrizpac]

paul williams and ricky hatton have no reason to be there.

Antonio Margarito was not on the P4P list when Williams beat him and that his William's only career win so far. You could argue that beating Quintana would be his other, but then that would be only 2 out of 10 top 10 WW's beat.

Ricky HAtton, well. Its Ricky Hatton.

Agreed with the above.

And trade Joe with JMM at 2. Other than that I like the list.

[WhoreUs]

Agreed with the above.

And trade Joe with JMM at 2. Other than that I like the list.

man marquez just lost a fight 7 months ago.

joe is were he should be.

ricky deserves to be on the p4p list.

who do you want there? calderon? who has he fought? seriously......

pavlik is on the list for beating jermain taylor , ricky can't be on the list for beating kostya ****ing tszyu?!?!!?!?

[KingArthur]

You have Ricky Hatton at #8?

exactly !!!!!!!!

[Dan...]

Hatton and Pavlik should not be there.

Cotto is borderline top 10, not number 5.

Margarito is too high.

Hopkins may be a bit low and Vasquez is too low.

WHERE THE *** IS MIJARES?!?!?!

Disgraceful list, just awful. The fact that Weebler doesn't see a lot wrong with it says it all.

[hammerhiem]

WHERE THE *** IS MIJARES?!?!?!

Do you honestly think anyone at the BBC has even heard of Mijares?

there isn't a single Superfly in the entire country that I know of and maybe 2 or three bantamweights who are recognised outside their own gym.

[2501]

Agreed with the above.

And trade Joe with JMM at 2. Other than that I like the list.

i like it when we are friends.

[Dan...]

Do you honestly think anyone at the BBC has even heard of Mijares?

there isn't a single Superfly in the entire country that I know of and maybe 2 or three bantamweights who are recognised outside their own gym.

I was evaluating the list on how accurate it is. I don't see how the points you raise have anything to do with the topic.

[Pullcounter]

I don't see much wrong with it, to be honest.

margarito is too high on the list. cotto and pavlik should be off. add the iron boy and mijares.

if you want u could take hatton off.... i mean he did only lose to the p4p #1 fighter, but you could put raf marquez up there.

[Pullcounter]

paul williams and ricky hatton have no reason to be there.

Antonio Margarito was not on the P4P list when Williams beat him

was cotto on the p4p list when margarito beat him?

was mosley on the p4p list when cotto beat him?

[Burner]

Williams is one of the top ten p4pounders in the sport.