Question for the Calzaghe haters...

[McAlister]

a better question would be... where would roy be after beating joe...

if joe is #1, and u beat the top dog... then that'd would make roy #1

[daggum]

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't.

[Dan...]

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't.

Calzaghe beat Bernard. That could potentially be a reason.

[starjammer]

hopkins should be much higher than windmill limbs. hopkins beat tarver, winky, pavlik and should have a win over calzaghe. windmill limbs has a SD against hopkins and he beat kessler who has faded into bolivian. how can calzaghe possibly be higher? he can't.

Let me explain how this works. If the guy at number 3 beats the guy at number 4, he stays ahead of him in the rankings, regardless of who number 4 beat in the past or future. If he couldn't beat number 3, he doesn't deserve to skip him.

It is very simple.

[Chunk..]

As my good mate R!ZO once said; ''At the end of the day, **** Calzaghe!''

[deemo]

i am a big calzaghe hater! i have him at #1 pound for pound. i don't see how people rate manny over him to be honest.i think bernard should be #2.or maybe if they could share the #1 spot.

[Tuggers1986]

lmao. I guess he thinks the OP was your alt?

Nice avi...the angry black guy

More like the DEAD black guy

[Burner]

*bump* hello???

It's funny how all my threads get ducked by all the Calz haters.

My top 3 are:

Pacman
Calzaghe
Hopkins

[Benny Leonard]

Just wondering...


Where do you put Calzaghe on the P4P list, where do you put Bhop?

I have Calzaghe at #2.

Not a hater.

I think he is a very good fighter and has a decent resume. He will go to the HOF.

[Benny Leonard]

i am a big calzaghe hater! i have him at #1 pound for pound. i don't see how people rate manny over him to be honest.i think bernard should be #2.or maybe if they could share the #1 spot.

Hahaha


I'm one of those that put Manny ahead of Joe.

One: Manny has fought in the States, away from his home, a lot longer. Points.

Two: Manny has moved up several weight divisions and Won titles. Points.

Three: Manny has kicked the crap out of some very good Mexican fighters. HOF fighters. Points.

Four: Manny is a Pimp outside of the ring. POINTS.

Five: Nike sponsers Manny. Points.

Six: Manny is God in his home country. Points.

Seven: Manny is Chinese...and I love Kung Fu movies

Eight: Manny is somehow able to run in L.A.

Nine: Manny took his team to the NL Championship this year.

Ten: Manny is exciting to watch.