New Ring P4P Rankings...

[Caxcan]

Cuz cotto is the better fighter and he still have a better resume than Margarito. Now let me ask you this, if DLH beats Pacman that means than DLH will be the #1 P4P?

margarito demolished cotto, he's the superior fighter regardless of styles

[Dan...]

Cuz cotto is the better fighter and he still have a better resume than Margarito. Now let me ask you this, if DLH beats Pacman that means than DLH will be the #1 P4P?

That is a different situation altogether.

I am a Cotto fan and I don't particularly like Margarito but I don't think I could find a way to put Cotto ahead of him on a p4p list right now.

I also like Calderon but I don't think he is top 5 p4p either. Pacquiao, Calzaghe, JMM, Hopkins, Vasquez, Mijares, Margarito at least should be placed above him. It is also debatable whether he is ahead of the likes of Wladimir Klitschko, Chad Dawson, Paul Williams, Miguel Cotto and a few others.

I would have both Cotto and Calderon in the lower region of my top 10 right now, perhaps even right on the edge at 10 and 11 or around there.

[FatNJerseykid]

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather(He'll hold this spot because I think he's coming back)
3. Calslaghe
4. JM Marquez
5. Vazquez
6. Margarito
7. Hopkins
8. Mijares
9. Cotto
10. Pavlik

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

That is a different situation altogether.

I am a Cotto fan and I don't particularly like Margarito but I don't think I could find a way to put Cotto ahead of him on a p4p list right now.

I also like Calderon but I don't think he is top 5 p4p either. Pacquiao, Calzaghe, JMM, Hopkins, Vasquez, Mijares, Margarito at least should be placed above him. It is also debatable whether he is ahead of the likes of Wladimir Klitschko, Chad Dawson, Paul Williams, Miguel Cotto and a few others.

I would have both Cotto and Calderon in the lower region of my top 10 right now, perhaps even right on the edge at 10 and 11 or around there.

thats why I told you that I respect what other people think about the P4P thing cuz, see this thing is assuming that this guy or that guy could beat this guy or the other guy if they where in the same weight?. thats why i think calderon should be a top 5. cuz I dont see how margarito, or Marquez, or Mijares or cotto could beat Calderon if they were in the same weight. Just my opinion. And about Cotto well he is still a better fighter than margarito, even though he lost to him.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

margarito demolished cotto, he's the superior fighter regardless of styles

Cotto still the better fighter and have the better resume. and have won titles in 2 divisions.

[Slotff]

Cotto still the better fighter and have the better resume. and have won titles in 2 divisions.

He still got crushed pretty brutally. His face was swollen and bloated and bleeding. He had nothing left and was cut, bleeding from the eye mouth and nose. Margarito left no room for interpretation of who was the better fighter. It was not even a come from behind KO. Margarito was ahead. No doubt, a great, incredibly brave showing from Cotto, but he was beaten down by a BETTER FIGHTER, not necessarily a FASTER fighter, or a SLICKER fighter, but a stronger, tougher, BETTER one, though a little less skilled than Cotto.

[Singularity]

Cuz cotto is the better fighter and he still have a better resume than Margarito. Now let me ask you this, if DLH beats Pacman that means than DLH will be the #1 P4P?

no because theyre in different weight classes plus unlike cotto pacquiao is an underdog
margarito defeated cotto at his weight class with his wba title at stake and showed who is the better man

[dainegerous]

...



Calderon for Pavlik ? ? ?

hmmmm

[Sage84]

Wheres Hatton??..........................

[dainegerous]

...

Wheres Hatton??..........................

hes at home...

washing the dishes...

lol