Who beat Hopkins more convincingly?

[3 P4PKING_2008]

Jones...............................

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Roy....knew it as soon as the final bell rang

[Ryn0]

Roy then Joe then Taylor and have never seen the Mitchell fight.

I thought Hop won the first Taylor fight and scored a draw in the second. I had Calzaghe winning by two rounds against B-Hop (that's one point due to the KD) and I had RJJ beating him convincingly (can't remember score)

[Pullcounter]

roy jones is the only person to beat him convincingly

agreed. every other fight was a razor thin decision.

[Stickman]

Oh my goodness, Pavlik, by far.

[KJB]

roy jones is the only person to beat him convincingly

Co-sign.
Both of the Taylor fights and the Calzaghe fight were very close.
I worry that in the future people will look at Hopkins losses and not give him the respect he deserves as an ATG MW.

[Tmb04]

I have a 39 fight collection of Hopkins. I seen the Roy Jones bout and Jones clearly won. Wasn't controversial, Hopkins wasn't robbed. RJ is the only convincing win against Hopkins that everyone can agree with.

[warp1432]

Roy Jones. Though I think Taylor won the first fight due to the inactiveness of Bernard. He started to late and landed some good things in the mean time like some jabs and body shots here and there.

[-Hyperion-]

roy beat him without a doubt..........

i thought calzaghe won comfortably on points.....but there were some swing rounds were people who are biased for hopkins style could make a case.....plus joe fought a ****** fight....

taylor won #1 without a doubt.......no way hopkins can make a case for winning more than 6 rounds......#2 was close as hell....but i gave it to taylor as well....

[K-Nan]

Jones, but hopkins is more in his prime now then he was when he was younger.I think Hopkins puts a beat down on roy now, actually I wouldn't even be shocked if prime vs prime that Hopkins would put a beat down on roy.

Because Hopkins' wins over anybody in his prime are comparable to beating Roy Jones?

Because an older Calzaghe of today can beat Hopkins of today (who is "in his prime now"), but a prime Jones couldn't?

Lol...