Better performance Vitali or Dawson?

[ACHlLLES]

Vitali beat a young determined buck, while Dawson disposed of an older fighter but talented fighter tarver... I think Dawson got hit more then Vitali though, but is tarver more talented then peter at this stage in tarvers career. Is it too hard to call?

[rizkybizness]

I was more impressed with Dawson because Dawson and Tarver were more evenly matched (physically). Although I was impressed with Vitali's CLEAR DOMINATION over Peter, it's pretty obvious he had such an easy time because of the sheer difference in height and reach. Vitali kept him at bay all night and kept unloading, I don't think we would be singing the same tune if Peter was the same height as Vitali.

[Dawerlzgreatest]

clitchko v peter was a TERRIBLE snoozefest

peter is toosmall...1 dimensional.. and old

and vitali moves like a geriatric


tarver v dawson was one sided ..but competitive talent and skill wise..dawson and tarver trump clit and peter in a landslide

[StillUnknown]

dawson because of the level of competition

[TheGreatA]

Dawson fought a disciplined fight and beat Tarver decisively but a 37 year old Vitali completely dominated a title holder after a 4 year layoff.

Peter is one of the worst title holders but it's still impressive.

[WLAD OWNS]

Vitali's performance was way more impressive

coming off a 4 year layoff and getting a dominant TKO win over Prime Sam Peter in 8 rounds (Peter had never been stopped before)

Dawson's UD win was impressive too....but Tarver was 40 years old and shot.....Prime Tarver vs Dawson would've been a different story

[Silencers]

Considering the circumstances, I think Klitschko's was more impressive.

[Steak]

hard to say, actually. Tarver at 39 is still way way better than Peter, but on the other hand, Vitali was coming off a big layoff...

the fact that he didnt get injured leading up to this fight is probebly the most impressive thing. puts both the victories to shame

[Dawerlzgreatest]

Vitali's performance was way more impressive

coming off a 4 year layoff and getting a dominant TKO over Prime Sam Peter in 8 rounds (Peter had never been stopped before)

Dawson's UD win was impressive too....but Tarver was 40 years old and shot.....Prime Tarver vs Dawson would've been a different story

tarver is in great shape for his age.. peter is shot (27?)

clitchko fought a small tomato can..thats what it came down to...not really impressive

not vitalis fault that hes 68 but it is what it is

[slicksouthpaw16]

Of course I'm going to say that Dawson impressed me personally the most, but with all of that aside Klitschko impressed the hell out of me, and i would like to see him clean up that horrible division. Incredible how someone could have a 4 year layoff and still look prime.