Floyd Mayweather is a (great!) fighter overall. He's just (good) at 147lbs though.

[alexdcolon]

I was replying to someones comments about who was best at ww. I stated no ww was (great) including Floyd Mayweather, just good. Styles of fighters make the fight. Depending on how they were matched up in a elimination style bracket tournement, any could end up on top. I believe Pretty-Boy is the only (great) fighters overall.....but at 147lbs. he is just good. and it matters because he will fight again.

[Sin City]

yup, at lightweight he is a great fighter. above, he didn't really prove himself at ww to consider him anything but good. if he would have fought the top guys then maybe it would have been different.

[Sin City]

a win over 2 of these 3 would make him great:
Cotto, Margarito, Williams.

[Tha_Greatest]

floyd mayweather is a great pusssy at welterweight

[boxasmash]

my thoughts exactly !

mayweather hasnt proved anything at 147 to make me believe he can beat cotto,williams and marg

[alexdcolon]

a win over 2 of these 3 would make him great:
Cotto, Margarito, Williams.

I would agree with that. Believe me, he will end up fighting again. Never against williams (not a good match up for him) but Cotto would be a great style for him and possibly margarito (slow and one dementional target). He's just going to let them beat each other up again and fight the winner. That would make him an amazing paycheck!