if oscar beats pacquiao

[mellymel420]

just because oscar beats pacquiao suddenly he is the number 1 p4p. why? the obvious is stated that oscar is the bigger man fighting a smaller opponent. plus not all his last fights were exciting. and why will floyd be number one again when he was number 1 p4p he never gave a exciting fight.

Since when pound4pound is about excitement?

It's about overall boxing skills of the boxer compare to other boxers in other divisions that determines that you're pound4pound king.

But Pac from Flyweight 112 to fighting @ 147 is simply AMAZING!!!

Pac to me is Pound4Pound is not simply because he's an exciting nor has great boxing skills. He's Pound4Pound becuz he was a former flyweight champion and now fighting @ 147 and NO former flyweight should have any business being in a ring against a welterweight. There's a reason why they have weight divisions. And Pac might figure that out this coming Dec. 6...

[toluco]

depends on who floyd fights
lets remember floyd was scared of giving oscar a rematch and all the welterweight division contenders

[sightseeker16]

BUT, if manny wins, it solidifies HIS claim to that rank...regardless of how impressive Calzaghe looks against Roy

Amen to that!!!

[4773Y350NM3]

the obvious answer would be money mayweather

[Burner]

Its Mayweather.....still.

[Burner]

depends on who floyd fights
lets remember floyd was scared of giving oscar a rematch and all the welterweight division contenders

What the hell?

[Eaner0919]

hold up, I'm asking the questions.

Assuming Pacquiao is No.1, if Oscar beats him, he becomes No.1 in most people's eyes, no?
or will Calzaghe take that slot after fighting Jones?

hell no why would he?

did you put Tarver as the p4p #1 when he beat Jones?

did you replace Hopkins with Taylor when Taylor beat him near the top of p4p?

[PoetryInMotion]

mayweather would have to beat someone in his own wieght class and on the top ten p4p list to ""earn"" a spot on the list in my opinion. Every one complains about the alphabet titles and how they just award fighters the belt without them having to fight a champion for it. they atleast got money to earn for their bias. Alot of you guys do the same thing with your p4p rankings just to nut hug. A guy dont just automaticlly earn a spot on the list just for being your fav. fighter. Floyd is off the list due to him retiring and inactivity and has to fight to be back on top. thats all there is to it IMO.

[Pullcounter]

oscar doesn't become p4p #1 for beating pac. the size disparity is just too great.

I think the p4p #1 status should be vacated when Pac loses, and that would force Pac to rematch JMM (who is #2) for the #1 spot.

[deemo]

does the outcome of bernard and kelly do anything for the p4p list and if so what