Who are the top 10 welterweights?

[KESSLER]

This is how I got it;

1. Antonio Margarito
2. Paul Williams
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Andre Berto (Even if he has a title).
6. Sebastian Lujan
7. Steve Forbes
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Carlos Quintana
10. Zab Judah

The bottom was really hard.

[KESSLER]

The bottom was really hard.

Especially since Judah dosen't belong in the top 10.

[Sox8055]

This is how I got it;

1. Antonio Margarito
2. Paul Williams
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Joshua Clottey
5. Andre Berto (Even if he has a title).
6. Sebastian Lujan
7. Steve Forbes
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Carlos Quintana
10. Zab Judah

The bottom was really hard.

Looks Good, I will rank Cotto on number 2 though. Even though he lost to Marg, He still has fought and beaten better competition. I even believe he will beat PWill if the fight ever happens..

[larryx]

champion-vacant
1-margo
1.5-williams
2-cotto
3-clottey
4-berto
5-quintana
6-cintron
7-collozo
the rest dont matter

[savorduhflavor]

Forbes is wayy too high. Quintana is definitely above him. IMO, Quintana should be above Cintron too. Quintana has wins over Paul Williams and Joel Julio. He's the only man to beat either one. Those two are bigger wins than Cintron's ever had. I'm of the opinion that Quintana is JUST outside being among the elite, but I'm definitely in the minority there. The list looks good, Cotto and Williams are interchangeable at #2 and 3, Margs is the clear #1. Yea I would just put Quintana ahead of Cintron and Forbes, but thats debatable.

[Eaner0919]

Lujan is too high. He hasnt had a signifigant win at welter in a while

Forbes hasnt had a win at welter period

no Collazo? no Soto Karass?

[KESSLER]

Looks Good, I will rank Cotto on number 2 though. Even though he lost to Marg, He still has fought and beaten better competition. I even believe he will beat PWill if the fight ever happens..

I think Cotto beats PWill aswell. I'd really like to see that fight.

[KESSLER]

Forbes is wayy too high. Quintana is definitely above him. IMO, Quintana should be above Cintron too. Quintana has wins over Paul Williams and Joel Julio. He's the only man to beat either one. Those two are bigger wins than Cintron's ever had. I'm of the opinion that Quintana is JUST outside being among the elite, but I'm definitely in the minority there. The list looks good, Cotto and Williams are interchangeable at #2 and 3, Margs is the clear #1. Yea I would just put Quintana ahead of Cintron and Forbes, but thats debatable.

I thought he proved he can hang with the welterweights in the Andre Berto fight. And Quintana just got destroyed by PWill so I thought I'd rank him above him. But, really, only the top 5 matters.

[KESSLER]

Lujan is too high. He hasnt had a signifigant win at welter in a while

Forbes hasnt had a win at welter period

no Collazo? no Soto Karass?

I forgot about Collazo. I think you can put him in instead of Judah.

[Sox8055]

I think Cotto beats PWill aswell. I'd really like to see that fight.

Definately....