Ring's P4P list

[Dark Destroyer]

does winky wright deserver to be fourth? i dont really know im asking.

Winky hasn't been given the respect he deserves for years. Only now the Shane Mosley lime light is on him he is getting the respect he does deserve. He is a great tactical fighter who utilises his lack of power well with a unbelieveable counter/combination punching defensive style. I have no issues with him been forth but Tarver at third is a joke.

BTW Winky will give us a replay of the first fight on November 20th when he fights Mosley again. Unless Mosley knocks him out i think he's lost again.

[Dude]

This list is one of the most ****** I've seen in recent times. Tarver 3rd? Toney at 9? Kostya still on the list? Funny in a sad kinda way.

[mic573]

Ring Magazine has never been good with rankings and p4p list so it is no surprise to me that thier list looks like that.

[syn0879]

I'm trying to figure out how they ranked Tarver #3.

[jabsRstiff]

Tarver deserves to be in the top 10, based on his demolition of the guy who topped many folks' lists.
But, we shoulda learned our lesson with VERNON FORREST. I, myself, was guilty of putting him up near the top based on his first win over Mosley (who was my #1 guy). Forrest looked like **** in the second fight, & we know about his fights with Mayorga.


I certainly can't see putting Tarver over Morales & Pac....two guys who have impressive BODIES OF WORK...not just a decent resume & one very stellar victory.

[QueenCity]

I never could understand how their P4P rankings can be so out of wack and their rankings for each weight class can be so well done.

[QueenCity]

Tarver deserves to be in the top 10, based on his demolition of the guy who topped many folks' lists.
But, we shoulda learned our lesson with VERNON FORREST. I, myself, was guilty of putting him up near the top based on his first win over Mosley (who was my #1 guy). Forrest looked like **** in the second fight, & we know about his fights with Mayorga.


I certainly can't see putting Tarver over Morales & Pac....two guys who have impressive BODIES OF WORK...not just a decent resume & one very stellar victory.

Thats kinda how I feel about Winky Wright, he can eventully a top pound for pound fighter, but not simply after I one great night against Shane Mosley. (a man who took a serious jump up in weight) It seems like everyone but me thinks he is right up there with the top fighters. I've always thought that Vargas won most of the rounds way back when they fought.

[guru]

look below

[Hurlex]

manny is to high...he cant be after JMM

[abdiel2k3]

POUND-FOR-POUND
1. BERNARD HOPKINS
Middleweight
2. FLOYD MAYWEATHER
Junior Welterweight
3. ANTONIO TARVER
Light Heavyweight
4. WINKY WRIGHT
Junior Middleweight
5. ERIK MORALES
Junior Lightweight
6. MANNY PACQUIAO
Featherweight
7. JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
Featherweight
8. KOSTYA TSZYU
Junior Welterweight
9. JAMES TONEY
Heavyweight
10. JOSE LUIS CASTILLO
Lightweight

makes sense for most part
cept id have JMM and PAC tied
i wouldnt have tzyu up there at all
Toney wouldnt be up there either
id prolly have corrales tied or one above castillo