Joe vs Roy

[wolfgang]

If roy is lucky and happens to beat joe, would you consider it his best win.

[Spiegelo]

If roy is lucky and happens to be joe, would you consider it his best win.

No, James Toney is a far better win in my eyes.

[Dan...]

It would probably still be Toney I think.

[El Dominicano]

Toney and B-Hop still is. More so Toney because B-Hop improved so much after that lost and I'm sure Toney would have beaten that version of B-Hop also.

[Scary]

I'd say probably. James Toney or him, no doubt about that.

But don't worry about it, Roy is in love with Joe, so if he was about to win, he'll let Joe win anyway!



haha!!

[Scary]

Uhm... Forgot to say that it clealy depends on how he wins.

[The_Italian]

If roy is lucky and happens to beat joe, would you consider it his best win.

i wouldnt call it his BEST win but it would be ONE OF the biggest wins of his career...especially considering he's not in his prime anymore.

it would say one of (maybe even) two things...

calzaghe isnt as good as he appears.

and/or

roy jones is STILL THAT good.

[j.razor]

If roy is lucky and happens to beat joe, would you consider it his best win.

1st it wont be lucky & it wont be his best win...by far...

[MANGLER]

Nope. Toney takes the cake.

[skyler]

At this point of time in hes career if hes able to beat Joe i will say i think thats a better win then the Toney win.