who would give mayweather the hardest fight, in order

[boxingsmash69]

in their primes, all fights being held at 147.

[ACHlLLES]

Why isn't cotto on that list?

[sugarshanenas]

Williams would give him the hardest imo, then Margarito,then Mayorga

I see him beating all 3 though

[PrettyBoyFloyd7]

all fights being held at 147.

1)Margarito has the best chance of beating PBF due to the high punch output,and great chin (I still believe Floyd would outclass him though).

2)Williams comes in second due to high punch output, height,and reach, but if Quintana can outbox Williams, PBF will box circles around the punisher.

3)Mayorga has no chance of beating PBF

[boxingsmash69]

Why isn't cotto on that list?

well, i just wanted to include 3 fighters who have alot of size advantage over floyd

[Scott9945]

I was looking for a choice without Mayorga in it.

[WaRCoTTo]

Why isn't cotto on that list?

Werd!..

[Miburo]

While Mayorga is the strongest of the three, his conditioning would make him the most minimal threat. Likewise Margarito is too wide open and slow. Williams has the best chance by reach and height advantages.

[boxingsmash69]

Werd!..

lol, hey man, trust me, cotto is my #1 favorite boxer right now (and i am filipino, wow, huh? how many filipinos can say that pacquiao is NOT their favorite?) and i wanted to include him, but i just cant help but wonder how mayweather would fight the giants that have a slugger style, or volume style (delahoya doesnt fight any of those 2)

[ACHlLLES]

Why is mayorga even on that ****ing list, he isn't even a 147 pounder...