I Disagree With Everyone!!!

[Scott9945]

disagree. Shane is a vastly superior boxer, yet he was not able to outbox mayorga. Shane rarely used his jab, clinching might have been avoided if he had jabbed. Mayorga would get close and clinch, Shane went along with it as well.

I'm still waiting to hear what Mayorga did to win more than a few rounds. All he was able to do was make Shane look bad. He didn't land any meaningful punches after the first few rounds.

[Dan...]

I was watching from the UK and had Mayorga winning. Mosely's timing and accuracy just seemed off.

But it did seem like HBO were only ever showing Shane's highlights (the occasional right hand) between rounds.

Our commentators had Mayorga wide and were basically saying Mosely should quit

I didn't see the fight but it sounds like your commentators were terrible. Had Mayorga wide? How is a guy landing half the jabs and power punches of his opponent well ahead? Sounds ridiculous to me. The most knowledgable guys on here all seem to think Mosley was winning.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I didn't see the fight but it sounds like your commentators were terrible. Had Mayorga wide? How is a guy landing half the jabs and power punches of his opponent well ahead? Sounds ridiculous to me. The most knowledgable guys on here all seem to think Mosley was winning.

How can you make a legit comment on it and even criticise those who scored it one way over another? Come on.... I hate when people do that.

Where you gettin this half the jabs, half the power punches stuff from anyway?

I would lean towards Mayorga wide than Mosley wide which is how I hear HBO had it. Like I said, Mosley looked really tentative, he was jabbing air most of the night. Dont get me wrong, Mayorga didnt exactly put on a clinic but he was winning the rounds in my book.

[DJ QUIK]

i saw you saying you had moyorga ahead in the 12 the and all the rest of what you had to say went out the window

[Guest]

How can you make a legit comment on it and even criticise those who scored it one way over another? Come on.... I hate when people do that.

Where you gettin this half the jabs, half the power punches stuff from anyway?

I would lean towards Mayorga wide than Mosley wide which is how I hear HBO had it. Like I said, Mosley looked really tentative, he was jabbing air most of the night. Dont get me wrong, Mayorga didnt exactly put on a clinic but he was winning the rounds in my book.

Almost all of the meaningful punches in the fight were landed by Mosley.
The rounds Mosley lost weren't because Mayorga was winning them decisively it was more that Shane at times wasn't doing enough. All the same, Mayorga won some rounds.

But Shane landed so many of the obvious punches and countered well, so I am pretty amazed that people had Mayorga ahead myself.
I had it 7-4 Mosley going into the 12th.
And Shane's accumulated punches are what did Mayorga in in the 12th.

[Dan...]

How can you make a legit comment on it and even criticise those who scored it one way over another? Come on.... I hate when people do that.

Where you gettin this half the jabs, half the power punches stuff from anyway?

I would lean towards Mayorga wide than Mosley wide which is how I hear HBO had it. Like I said, Mosley looked really tentative, he was jabbing air most of the night. Dont get me wrong, Mayorga didnt exactly put on a clinic but he was winning the rounds in my book.

It's true I didn't see it and I qualified my post by stating that up front. It just seems that pretty much all the most knowledgable guys on here scored it for Mosley and he dominated the punch stats also so it just seems that having it wide for Mayorga is a little strange.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

It's true I didn't see it and I qualified my post by stating that up front. It just seems that pretty much all the most knowledgable guys on here scored it for Mosley and he dominated the punch stats also so it just seems that having it wide for Mayorga is a little strange.

Its amazing how punch stats are flavour of the week when it suits people.

Having it wide for Mayorga may have been a push but I couldve seen 6-5, 7-4 easily. Mosley had 2 great rounds the whole fight. Whether you had him ahead or not, he didnt look good at all.

[Dan...]

Its amazing how punch stats are flavour of the week when it suits people.

Having it wide for Mayorga may have been a push but I couldve seen 6-5, 7-4 easily. Mosley had 2 great rounds the whole fight. Whether you had him ahead or not, he didnt look good at all.

I actually don't place a lot of stock in them, I just threw it in there. I haven't seen it so I have to take what I can get. I was mainly going on the opinions of those who I think are right 99% of the time.

[Darkstar]

Mayorga won 7 rounds at the least. Mayorga by SD.

[letsgobrady]

I had it 6-4-1 for Mayorga going in the 12th rd. Shane was not doing anything in the fight, Mayorga made the fight.

i had it 6-4-1 for shane.mayorga looked better in this fight than he did in the delahoy trinidad fights