Who is a better boxer...Castillo or Margarito?

[Pullcounter]

Simple question. Who had more versatility, skill, could change ranges, footwork, better boxing IQ and overall skills? Margarito or Castillo? Vote.

Castillo was/is/will always be the better boxer. margarito just has a great chin, great stamina and decent power.

[deevel79]

Castillo, but that doesnt mean he would beat Margarito given they were in the same weight class. Cotto had all the advantages u mentioned, and look what happened to him.

[deevel79]

Castillo...

Taking nothing away from Tony, he isn't really skilled. Tough as nails guy, great chin, good power, heart, and a lot of stamina is how he wins. He doesn't outskill guys, he out wills them.

Spot on! Excellent post!

[-MAKAVELLI-]

It took some serious skill and determination to give PBF his toughest test…goin with JLC

[mellow_mood]

i voted for castillo....

with that being said..

marg has been WAY MORE PRODUCTIVE with his lack of SKILLS..than THE 7 WONDER CASTILLO...

[Jose Rizal]

It took some serious skill and determination to give PBF his toughest test…goin with JLC

The rematch though kind of proved Floyd's point that he wasn't 100% in the first fight. Still, excuse or no excuse, Castillo deserved the nod in that one.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Basically.

LOL:

Margarito
boxeador13, chicano79us

I wonder who would be your next name in having more Skills than Marg Thread. Hatton? Baldomir? Mayorga? You're a hater to the fullest bro.

[KostyaTszyu44]

what sort of a Q is that? jose is more skilled by a mile


man i feel sorry for jose, other day on a boxing program i saw highlights of him losing a UD to some bum...man is he shot i hope he can leave boxing soon i heard he has money troubles that explains why he is fighting still hope he can leave with all his faculties intact but i doubt it

[bsrizpac]

what sort of a Q is that? jose is more skilled by a mile


man i feel sorry for jose, other day on a boxing program i saw highlights of him losing a UD to some bum...man is he shot i hope he can leave boxing soon i heard he has money troubles that explains why he is fighting still hope he can leave with all his faculties intact but i doubt it

Obviously some margetards dont think so.

[AztecWanker]

castillo by a mile