mayweather retired unproven

[boxasmash]

5 weight champions doesnt count for **** when the only top fighter in a division you beat is castillo who has lost to many others and some think he even beat floyd.

[Weebler I]

Agreed. His heart wasn't in boxing anyway, he wanted to be a rapper and a gangster.

[Haglerwins]

Not fighting the monsters at WW is understandable, but he should've at least closed the show with Mosely and Cotto.

[Kilrain]

He beat the man at super feather(Corrales), the man at lightweight( Castillo), the man at super-lightweight (albeit when he was a welter; Hatton), and, really, justifiably, the man at super welterweight (Oscar). Something to think about.

[badboypeenoy]

Don't worry he'll be returning against Pacman next year.

[Flawless.]

Calzaghe proven against Eubank or maybe 43 year old Hopkins or was it Reid

BHAHAHAHAA

[Dan...]

Floyd's achievements at 130 alone make him a proven fighter. He demolished the best at that weight.

[da_beast]

he beat some good boxers along the way. i am not his biggest fan. The first Castillo fight i believe he lost but hey thats life. there have been worse decisions in boxing.

He is/was one of the all time greats. as much as i hate the guy i cant argue with that

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

He beat the man at super feather(Corrales), the man at lightweight( Castillo), the man at super-lightweight (albeit when he was a welter; Hatton), and, really, justifiably, the man at super welterweight (Oscar). Something to think about.

Quite true.

Interesting how Mayweather's resume is questioned, but there are very few in his era with better resumes (I'm looking at YOU, Calzaghe).

[MANGLER]

At WW yeah, but he's retired period, so **** it.