Zab Judah vs. Joan Guzman at 140

[El Dominicano]

I've alwayz said Zab would be the top dog at 140. I'd still give Guzman a really good chance but I don't see anyone beating Zab at 140.

[kenso]

judah takes it

[Zocalo]

Yeah Lets give Judah another main event. He has earned losing to all of the top fighters. Judah's best victory wa sover CHOP CHOP Corley, but barely.

I would say his best victory was his KO of Spinks, the that guy JT couldn't knockout. Common, he made the fight watchable...

[Zocalo]

Anyways I think Judah despite all his shortcomings, he just the better fighter at 140. He is a natural junior welterweight in my opinion. We don't know how Guzman would look adding 10 more lbs vs a quality fighter.

[Dambala]

I really like Guzman, if he would've fought Campbell he'd be considered to enter the top 10 at the p4p list, but at 140, Zab (in his prime) would own him.

[boxaholic]

I would say his best victory was his KO of Spinks, the that guy JT couldn't knockout. Common, he made the fight watchable...

Spinks. LOL. Spinks is a feather puncher that never beat anybody. The only good thing Zab has going for him is his name. Zab loses to every A fighter and beats The B class. That doesn't make him among the top 10 at 147 and 140 now. Maybe in his prime but when was Zabs prime?

[Zocalo]

Spinks. LOL. Spinks is a feather puncher that never beat anybody. The only good thing Zab has going for him is his name. Zab loses to every A fighter and beats The B class. That doesn't make him among the top 10 at 147 and 140 now. Maybe in his prime but when was Zabs prime?

He was the unified welterweight champ... He beat Piccirillo and then Mayorga. The same Mayorga that had 2 back to back ass whuppings of one Forrest. If you want to discredit that, well that is fine.

I mean if you are going to bash Spinks for being featherfisted why not bash Calderon and Malignaggi.

[MWMerlino]

Guzman by UD -- Zab looked good against Clottey but he still has that habit of pulling straight back and leaving himself open. I don't see Guzman getting caught with a counter right uppercut.

[boxaholic]

He was the unified welterweight champ... He beat Piccirillo and then Mayorga. The same Mayorga that had 2 back to back ass whuppings of one Forrest. If you want to discredit that, well that is fine.

I mean if you are going to bash Spinks for being featherfisted why not bash Calderon and Malignaggi.

Paulie is garbage. Calderon is head and sholders better than his competition. When did he beat Mayorga???????????

[boxaholic]

He was the unified welterweight champ... He beat Piccirillo and then Mayorga. The same Mayorga that had 2 back to back ass whuppings of one Forrest. If you want to discredit that, well that is fine.

I mean if you are going to bash Spinks for being featherfisted why not bash Calderon and Malignaggi.

Forrest got KO'D by Mayorga in Temecula, Ca the first fight but the second fight was a very close fight that could have gone either way. The second fight was at The Orleans in Vegas and Corley vs Judah was the undercard. I was at both fights and had the second fight a draw and Zab beating Corley 115-112