Does This Logic Work?

[dobermann28]

take oscar de la hoya,shane mosley,miguel cotto,and antonio margirito...

which one of these fighters is the best?

logic would say margirito is the best and oscar de la hoya is the worst!

as shane beat oscar,cotto beat shane,and margirito beat cotto...

but i can't decide if this makes sence...looking at each fighter i would say oscar is the best and mosley the worst...but how can that be is mosley beat oscar...twice.

tell me if im a ****ing nutcase of if what i just said made sense...

and also tell me who you think is best. and worst.

and if any logic like this makes sence or if it is all bull****.

cheers

[Zocalo]

Well that was the logic Mayorga had when he faced Oscar...

[RodBarker]

Just understand the triangle phenomenon in boxing and your logic goes out the window.

[MANGLER]

**** on the triangle theory. Only way to tell who's the better man between 2 fighters is for them to fight each other.

[RodBarker]

**** on the triangle theory. Only way to tell who's the better man between 2 fighters is for them to fight each other.

Agree with your 1on1 but the triangle is well proven