Wo is Really High Between the two P4P.. JMM or Calzaghe?

[Migs]

It is facts.. I'm not making up stories about JMM.. I'd rather be pissed about myself if i'm only inventing stories.. It maybe hate, but it is the truth.

Just look at the Poll if I'm biased.

Your presentation of the topic was biased. My guess though is due to the way you go about creating your threads, not as many people on NSB will partake in your polls as they would for a more objective poster.

[MakeDamnSure]

Good Thread.. I have Calzaghe still as P4P#2 than Marquez.. We all know Casamayor lost to Sta. Cruz badly. Joe being undefeated and had 21 title defenses is not a joke. JMM mmay have close fights with Pacquiao but the fact is he never won.

[Pugilistic™]

Marquez and Calzaghe both have a case to be number 2 pound for pounders.

Marquez gave number 1 p4p Pacquiao his toughest fights and argueably won them both. Barrera was past his prime but was still a very good fighter. Casamayor even though got a very questionable win over Santa Cruz and was almost out against Katsidis but came back to knock him out still is a skilled fighter and was the Linear champ at 135, even though he is no longer his best still made the fight competitive plus has a good chin and Marquez became the first man to stop him.

Calzaghe is undefeated and just finished dominating the supermiddleweight division after defending his title successful 21 times and beating in impressive fashion Kessler and Lacy who at the time were young undefeated Champs. He then moved up and won the light heavyweight title in a close SD win where he didn't put on his best performance but did enough to win. What makes his win over Hopkins better is the fact that Hopkins just had two wins over former p4p fighters Tarver and Wright, Even though he is 43 clearly he is a top fighter and is a good win on Calzaghe's resume.

[Tmb04]

JMM easily. Say What you want about his oppenents. He still fought better opposition in his career