Latest Ring Mag P4P: Marquez to #2, Calzaghe down to #3

[PrettyBoyFloyd7]

http://www.thering-online.com/ringpages/ratings2.html

1 MANNY PACQUIAO
2 JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
3 JOE CALZAGHE
4 BERNARD HOPKINS
5 ISRAEL VAZQUEZ
6 ANTONIO MARGARITO
7 KELLY PAVLIK
8 CRISTIAN MIJARES
9 RAFAEL MARQUEZ
10 MIGUEL COTTO

Agree or Disagree?

thats an accurate list. except for Hopkins being at 4..He should be moved down a few notches.

[BlackHat]

JMM should be no.1!!! this list is bias!! JMM will fight Vernon and this will prove that he is the no.1 p4p fighter!

[letsgobrady]

no way should marquez be higher than joe

[Boofdatruth]

Cotto does not belong in the top 10 pfp list. You have to put Williams at 9 or 10. I'd also drop Raf Marquez out of the top 10. Cotto and Raf should be just outside the top 10 looking in.

[Floyd Sinclair]

Cotto does not belong in the top 10 pfp list. You have to put Williams at 9 or 10. I'd also drop Raf Marquez out of the top 10. Cotto and Raf should be just outside the top 10 looking in.

Boof always has the best looking girls in his avi's :wank:

[NeXt In Line]

As a HUGE Hopkins fan, I don't think he deserves to be at #4 P4P, I mean the same argument for him is always there, which is that at 43, going on 44 he's still an elite fighter, which is true, dropping Joe Calzaghe in their fight is no easy task.

However, his style, stamina and techniques have gone downhill with age, as is expected, he should be down more towards the bottom, maybe in the top 13 or so? IF he beats Pavlik convincingly, I have no problem with him being in the Top 5 at all.

To answer the original question, I think Marquez at #2 is a good thing. He KO'd Casamayor, moving up in weight in his first fight at 135, and even though Casa's a bit older, I think a KO over him is better than Pac-Man's KO over Diaz.

[Boofdatruth]

Cotto does not belong in the top 10 pfp list. You have to put Williams at 9 or 10. I'd also drop Raf Marquez out of the top 10. Cotto and Raf should be just outside the top 10 looking in.

I have...

1. Cal

2. J.M.M

3. Pac Money Bags

After removing Cotto and Raf, you could throw in at the moment:

Campbell, Wlad, Calderon, Donaire, John, or Dawson. JMO

[Boofdatruth]

Boof always has the best looking girls in his avi's :wank:

My man Gold lol. Fishscale lol. The Ghost in in the building lol. Peace Gold.

[Boofdatruth]

Boof always has the best looking girls in his avi's :wank:

And you can't go wrong with Bernard King against Detroit or James Toney in your sig lol.

[letsgobrady]

marquez win over cassamayor is better than mannys win over diaz but this you can probably say is the biggest win for marquez all his other big fights are close fights i felt like even the fight with cassamyor was a close fight marquez doesn't ever win that decisive thats why i don't believe he should be #2