James Toney vs. Marvin Hagler @ 168?

[boxingsmash69]

who snatches this victory?

[Dan...]

Hagler. Prime Hagler was very close to unbeatable. I think he stops James on accumulation.

[El Dominicano]

who snatches this victory?

OMG! I voted JT by accident!

[MELLY-MEL...]

my man marvin

[AntonTheMeh]

i gotta go with toney.marvelous was a career middle.

[Truth]

Tough call. I'm tempted to pick Toney because of his defense and iron chin, but I also tempted to pick Marvin Hagler because of his power and speed. I honestly don't know what to say...

this is a good thread...**** i don't what to say. maybe i should just say I don't remember anything like Mike Tyson did after his fight with Holyfield.

I don't remember anything sir.

[Xyei]

Two of my all time favorites. I'd go with Hagler though. I don't think Hagler would stop Toney but I think he'd win clearly.

[marsman]

James Toney @ 168 is pure magic. I see him doing to Hagler what he did to Holyfield. Obliterate him with skill. NO K.O cause Hagler aint goin down, but pure cuts and clean punches will win him the decision. I cant even picture Hagler beating him.

[Truth]

Two of my all time favorites. I'd go with Hagler though. I don't think Hagler would stop Toney but I think he'd win clearly.

i don't remember anything sir, its all a blur to me. lol

[-Swizzy-]

this isn't quite as straight forward as ppl think. I voted Hagler but I really had to bite down and think about it. and really I think I gave it to hagler just because of his accomplishments. This would have been a decision no doubt but I don't know who would have gotten it. Toney is the smart boxer and hagler is the tough grinder. they both mismatch each others style and are both very good at what they do. Don't know who would win this one really.