James Toney vs. Joe Calzaghe at SMW--Prime who wins?

[T-97]

Would've been nice to see JT landing a counter right as RJJ jumped in...ah well.

Would be nice to see Toney come into a heavyweigth fight in good shape as well

[MWMerlino]

Would be nice to see Toney come into a heavyweigth fight in good shape as well

yeah...****in guy is finally gettin serious at the ripe age of 40...

[T-97]

yeah...****in guy is finally gettin serious at the ripe age of 40...

He's just hitting his peak! I wish....

[MWMerlino]

the desperation is there...he's calling out klitschko and peter because he wants a legitimate HW title.

[T-97]

the desperation is there...he's calling out klitschko and peter because he wants a legitimate HW title.

I think he's calling out Klitschko for a payday, same with Peter. Although, I suppose he has a chance of beating Peter..He nearly did the first time.

I don't think he has much drive left, he didn't exactly come into the Rahman rematch in good shape. Klitschko would TKO him imo.

[P4P Opinion]

Just so I can keep this clear in my head, is this the same James Toney who lost twice to Montell Griffin?

[boxasmash]

Just so I can keep this clear in my head, is this the same James Toney who lost twice to Montell Griffin?

yes ...

[T-97]

Just so I can keep this clear in my head, is this the same James Toney who lost twice to Montell Griffin?

Think of the Toney that fought The Blade

[P4P Opinion]

Think of the Toney that fought The Blade

Yeh, I know the Toney who lost to Griffin wasn't prime, but still I have difficulty picking a fighter who lost to MONTEL FRICKIN' GRIFFIN not once, but TWICE.

[T-97]

Yeh, I know the Toney who lost to Griffin wasn't prime, but still I have difficulty picking a fighter who lost to MONTEL FRICKIN' GRIFFIN not once, but TWICE.

True,

Toney had ups and downs, like me, boxasmash and MWMerlino said earlier. His eating habbits meant he could look great one time, then aweful another. In a fantasy match up of them both on their best night I think Toney wins a close fight. In reality, Calzaghe would probably win as Toney would probably be drained.