Gatti vs Hatton @ 140lbs who wins?

[PWESTNYC]

Gatti at 140 didn't carry the same advantages that he did at 135. At 135 he was bigger than most and hit harder than most. At 140 Hatton wears him down, Gatti wouldn't win on points because Gatti likes to eat to many punches. The only way he wins is KO. I'll go with Hatton clear UD.

Gatti grew into 140 fairly well by the time he was fighting Ward.

Nobody put a dent in him at that weight until Floyd and that is nothing to be ashamed of.

Hatton can be hurt just the same as Gatti. Pick em fight. Very exciting and explosive

[Mayfeather]

Would be an awesome fight I reckon Hatton to win though

[Silencers]

Hatton would've knocked Gatti out IMO, Gatti was one exciting fighter but he wasn't that good, Hatton would've just been too much for him.

[rj_ct]

gatti by late ko, but he was never the same after the ward fights, and straight up damaged goods after the mayweather fights, so i guess it would depend on when the fight took place.

[The Wire]

You taking any more bets on Pac-Oscar?

How much, dawg?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

This almost happened at 147. Would've been a great fight at 140. I think Hatton would've been too strong and stopped him late.

[bsrizpac]

After watching the Gatti vs Ward epic..I have always wondered what would havehappened if these two met @ 140 in the primes......I have seen Gatti take some brutal punches and come back raging to KO his opponents...I have also seen Gatti step back and box some and win on points.....Hatton has that mauling move forward style and never stops punching leans clinches and goes to the body.....I truely am tossed up on who I would put money on if they had fought in their primes......I even once had the computer (PS3) go head to head sat back and watched with a pint in hand and enjoyed an 8 round KO for Gatti.......i still wasn't sure ....what do you guys think? I am going to have to go with Gatti @ 140 in his prime on pure guts and determination alone......Lefty

****** question: When was Gatti's prime at 140? I mean to say that after the Ward fights he was def. ruined and after the Floyd fight he was even worse. Before the Ward fights I'm not even sure he was filled out at that weight yet.

I guess the best time would be right before his first Ward fight.

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Would be an awesome fight I reckon Hatton to win though

I agree would have been action packed and awsome...Some of you fellas get to much into detail it is a fantasy matchup everything here is what if? Well what if Gatti was in hs prime at 140? What if Gatti would have fought Hatton at 140 rather then Ward? What if?......Lefty

[Derranged]

Gatti grew into 140 fairly well by the time he was fighting Ward.

Nobody put a dent in him at that weight until Floyd and that is nothing to be ashamed of.

Hatton can be hurt just the same as Gatti. Pick em fight. Very exciting and explosive

Did you forget DLH???

[rj_ct]

I agree would have been action packed and awsome...Some of you fellas get to much into detail it is a fantasy matchup everything here is what if? Well what if Gatti was in hs prime at 140? What if Gatti would have fought Hatton at 140 rather then Ward? What if?......Lefty

true, but there is some logic to it. the ward and mayweather fights took a lot out of him. his reflexes and ability to take a punch had declined. it's all hypothetical anyway, so adding a few more hypotheticals makes sense.