Edison Miranda vs prime Antwun Echols at 160, who takes it?

[El Chicano]

Who wins a throwdown between these two powerhouses?

[Dan...]

Good thread.

I must apologise for my previous abusive attitude towards you. Your last few threads have been top quality.

[Dan...]

I'm going to go with prime Echols at 160 on the basis that he had more boxing ability than Miranda does. He wasn't simply a one-dimensional slugger.

[mspiegelo]

i meant to vote antwun ko.... antwun wouldnt have gotten caught by edison- he's a horrendous boxer....

[warp1432]

Antwun had some great power back in the day man. Keep in mind at 168 he was decked twice by Charles Brewer, then came back in the third round to stop him. Sure I've read that stoppage is a little iffy, but still.

Echols I think would beat Miranda because that dude has some serious power. Even more then Miranda I would say.

[Silencers]

I'm going with Echols by knockout but anything can happen in this fight, I'm picking Echols because I think he's the better fighter technically but that could go out the window once he gets hit by Miranda.

[oldgringo]

I'll take Echols in his prime. '97-'00 Echols probably stops him...I'm thinking about the guy who stopped Brian Barbosa and was supposed to give Hopkins a tough time. He hit like a mule and was slightly more technically proficient than Miranda.

Like Silencers said though, could be a toss up considering Miranda's punching power. I'll stick with Echols though.

[Scott9945]

Damn good matchup.

[El Chicano]

Good thread.

I must apologise for my previous abusive attitude towards you. Your last few threads have been top quality.

Sometimes I get drunk and post ****ty threads, my bad.