Zab Judah VS Ricky Hatton at 140

[TheGreatAli]

Judah has taken on more top contenders than most WW and JWW.

How do you see Ricky Hatton who got lucky to have a homer ref saving him from a KO by Juan Lazcano beating Zab Judah?

Zab Judah who has went 12 rounds with Mayweather ( a guy who KOed Hatton)

Key word fought. he's only beaten Spinks and he's even lost to him too.

Don't make me laugh..

[The Gully Gad]

I would have to say casper Hatton
Judah is a danger though and that uppercut of his is catching Hatton everytime

[fightingfigs]

What did Zab used to be?

This is what I find comical, Zab was NEVER an elite fighter.

Was he elite when he got KOed in two by Tszyu?
Was he elite when he lost to Baldomir?
Was he elite when he lost to Spinks?
Was he elite when he lost to Mayweather?
Was he elite when he got KOed by Cotto?
Was he elite when he lost to Clottey?

If anything, he looked better against Clottey then he did against Baldomir and Spinks.

Quit with this Zab BS now, Zab was never a top fighter.

Kostya got lucky that the ref called it early.
Baldomir was highway Robbery ( Zab didnt even train hard for that due to Don King making him promote)
He KOed Spinks in a rematch
He went 12 rounds with Mayweather which in my opinion couldve been a draw.

I say he convincingly lost to Cotto but Cotto was pestering and swarming for 11 hard fought rounds, He staggered Cotto even worse than Margarito did as well.

Clottey was also a robbery, it went to the scorecards and I feel Zab won most of the rounds by being busier and connecting more punches. it shouldve been a draw or Zab by decision

[ophqui]

Lazcano almost pulled off an upset

He really didnt. . .it wasnt a close fight just because hatton was momentarily rocked by a punch.


as i said before, my gut ALWAYS tells me to pick judah. i picked him (for real money on betfred) against cotto, baldy, mayweather, clottey and mosely, i've lost a lot of money on that guy, would have been even more if the shane fight went ahead. Again my gut says judah, but im done picking the guy, he's a flake, he has serious mental problems, i think hes a great case study in 'unworthiness,' subconsiously he beleives he's not good enough to win, so even when he's clearly the better fighter he finds a way to lose (see the ridiculousness against cotto with the low blows, see the clottey cut, see numerous other examples of him bitching out of fights he could have won). anyone who has an interest in psychology may have observed something similar and i really beleive this to be the case. I'd pick hatton based on the fact that he actually wants to win fights and goes until he's laid out on his back

[5punchcombo]

Kostya got lucky that the ref called it early.
Baldomir was highway Robbery ( Zab didnt even train hard for that due to Don King making him promote)
He KOed Spinks in a rematch
He went 12 rounds with Mayweather which in my opinion couldve been a draw.

I say he convincingly lost to Cotto but Cotto was pestering and swarming for 11 hard fought rounds, He staggered Cotto even worse than Margarito did as well.

Clottey was also a robbery, it went to the scorecards and I feel Zab won most of the rounds by being busier and connecting more punches. it shouldve been a draw or Zab by decision

Hatton got KOed by mayweathers speed. Imagine what a Zab Judah could do. I dont think Ricky Hatton would go 5 rounds with Clottey. Zab would win against Ricky Hatton now. I think Ricky is shot.

[xEDDIEx]

What did Zab used to be?

This is what I find comical, Zab was NEVER an elite fighter.

Was he elite when he got KOed in two by Tszyu?
Was he elite when he lost to Baldomir?
Was he elite when he lost to Spinks?
Was he elite when he lost to Mayweather?
Was he elite when he got KOed by Cotto?
Was he elite when he lost to Clottey?

If anything, he looked better against Clottey then he did against Baldomir and Spinks.

Quit with this Zab BS now, Zab was never a top fighter.

first off i HATE zab judah so im not someone thats just gonna stick up for him no matter what. but, the late 90's-early 00's zab that beat micky ward and junior witter was a much better fighter than we see today. im not saying that he could beat hatton, but definately give him a fight.

[fightingfigs]

Key word fought. he's only beaten Spinks and he's even lost to him too.

Don't make me laugh..

Only thing that makes me laugh is your sig.

Thats a nice picture but can you remind me what the outcome of that fight was? I forgot.

[The Gully Gad]

Kostya got lucky that the ref called it early.

Figs ur cool brother but hell no did Kostya get lucky against Judah.
**** Judah is my boy also but he got checked that day bro

[5punchcombo]

Kostya got lucky that the ref called it early.
Baldomir was highway Robbery ( Zab didnt even train hard for that due to Don King making him promote)
He KOed Spinks in a rematch
He went 12 rounds with Mayweather which in my opinion couldve been a draw.

I say he convincingly lost to Cotto but Cotto was pestering and swarming for 11 hard fought rounds, He staggered Cotto even worse than Margarito did as well.

Clottey was also a robbery, it went to the scorecards and I feel Zab won most of the rounds by being busier and connecting more punches. it shouldve been a draw or Zab by decision

Thats almost all true but I think Mayweather deserved the win.

It was close but Mayweather was teh aggressor

[TheGreatAli]

first off i HATE zab judah so im not someone thats just gonna stick up for him no matter what. but, the late 90's-early 00's zab that beat micky ward and junior witter was a much better fighter than we see today. im not saying that he could beat hatton, but definately give him a fight.

Judah was terrible against Witter.

He was on the verge of being stopped against Clottey, no where near beating Mayweather and Baldomir beat him easily.

I know he's your favorite fighter but please...