Zab Judah is not an inconsistent fighter.

[THE REED]

If you know the actual definition of inconsistent, something that is one way, and then completely opposite, going back and forth. To be good and then not good... to win and then not win... I just don't see how Zab is inconsistent.

If he beat Floyd Mayweather, and then lost to Cotto, and then beat Clottey, I would say Zab is inconsistent.

When he fought Floyd, if he won rounds 1,3,5,7,9,11.. and lost 2,4,6,8,10,12... I would say hes inconsistent..

He isn't...

He lost to Floyd, Cotto, and Clottey... and does well in rounds 1-6 and that's it. (although in his last fight I thought he fought well... but also thought if the fight continued he could very well be stopped).

That's not inconsistent, hes just not an elite fighter. I would give him the gatekeeper position of the division though... Zab doesn't suck, but hes not great. If you can beat him, your ready for the elite, if you can't beat him, your not ready for the elite.

THIS IS Zab Judah, that is the fighter he is... Someone whose talented, but not in every part of the game... Boxing is as much mental as it is physical, Zab has the physcial, but doesn't have the mental... thats it, it isn't going to magically appear 70% into his career... This is who he is.

[IMDAZED]

100% Agree.

Zab's not inconsistent, he's just not that good. I mean, he was getting dropped left and right BEFORE he fought Tszyu. And he has one significant win. Inconsistent? Nah. Overrated? YES.

[ophqui]

I still think on the right night zab could take anyone (PBF included), but im done picking him against solid opponents.

He is inconsistant in that one minute he's dominating and hurting superstars (see the first rounds with floyd and cotto) the next he's getting manhandled by carlos baldomir. Your right though his results have been pretty consistant recently

[IMDAZED]

I still think on the right night zab could take anyone (PBF included), but im done picking him against solid opponents.

He is inconsistant in that one minute he's dominating and hurting superstars (see the first rounds with floyd and cotto) the next he's getting manhandled by carlos baldomir. Your right though his results have been pretty consistant recently

Domination lasts more than one minute. And that's Zab's problem.

[RichCCFC]

Exactly.

Zab Judah is the most overrated piece of **** I've ever seen. He's just got fast hands like Lacy just has power.

This makes him one dimensional.

[rizkybizness]

Exactly.

Zab Judah is the most overrated piece of **** I've ever seen. He's just got fast hands like Lacy just has power.

This makes him one dimensional.

Piece of ****? You're the piece of ****.

[RichCCFC]

Piece of ****? You're the piece of ****.

Fat boy

[THE REED]

ease up on the circle jerk fellas

[THE REED]

100% Agree.

Zab's not inconsistent, he's just not that good. I mean, he was getting dropped left and right BEFORE he fought Tszyu. And he has one significant win. Inconsistent? Nah. Overrated? YES.

thats my point, i just dont think Zab is that good... how many big fights do you have to lose to finally come to the conclusion, you know what, maybe he just ISNT THAT good...

[The Gully Gad]

Exactly Judah does not have the mental aspect of the game locked down
His got crazy skills but is always lacking
His a Frontrunner......